HomeMy WebLinkAboutResolution - 2013-R0152 - 1115 Healthcare Transformation Services Agreement - LRMHMRC Dba Starcare - 05/09/2013Resolution N0. 2013-80152
May 9, 2013
Item No.5.12
RESOLUTION
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LUBBOCK:
THAT the Mayor of the City of Lubbock is hereby authorized and directed to
execute for and on behalf of the City of Lubbock, a 1115 Healthcare Transformation
Services Agreement by and between the City of Lubbock and Lubbock Regional Mental
Health Mental Retardation Center DBA StarCare Specialty Health System, and related
documents. Said Agreement is attached hereto and incorporated in this resolution as if
fully set forth herein and shall be included in the minutes of the City Council.
Passed by the City Council on May 9, 2013
GPKC. ROBERTSON, MAYOR
ATTEST:
RebelVa Garza, City Seer t
APPROVED AS TO
Manager
Community Services
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
�4k-t,4�
Chad Weaver, Assistant City Attorney
v :ecdocs/RES.Agrmt-StarCare
May 2, 2013
StarCare Specialty Health System
1115 Healthcare Transformation Services Agreement
City of Lubbock
THIS AGREEMENT is entered into by and between the entities shown below:
Lubbock Regional Mental Health Mental Retardation Center
DBA StarCare Specialty Health System (StarCare)
P.O. Box 2828
Lubbock, Texas 79408-2828
City of Lubbock
P.O. Box 2000
Lubbock, Texas 79401
BACKGROUND:
In December 2011, Texas received federal approval of an 1115 Healthcare Transformation waiver that would
allow for managed care expansion to additional areas of the state. Under the 1115 Transformation Waiver,
supplemental payment funding, managed care savings, and negotiated funding will go into a Delivery System
Reform Incentive Payment (DSRIP) pool to incentivize hospitals and other providers to transform their service
delivery practices to improve quality, health status, patient experience, coordination, and cost-effectiveness.
Eligibility to get DSRIP payments required participation in a regional healthcare partnership. Within a
partnership, participants include governmental entities providing public funds known as intergovernmental
transfers (IGT), Medicaid providers and other stakeholders. Participants were required to develop a regional
plan identifying partners, community needs, the proposed projects, and funding distribution. Each partnership
must have one anchoring entity, which acts as a primary point of contact for the Health and Human Services
Commission (HHSC) in the region and is, responsible for seeking regional stakeholder engagement and
coordinating development of a regional plan.
The following agencies established the Regional Healthcare Partnership 12 (RHP 12) and submitted a RHP Plan
to expand services in Lubbock, Randall and Potter counties: University Medical Center (UMC), the City of
Lubbock and StarCare. UMC is the designated anchoring entity and acts as the primary point of contact for the
Health and Human Services Commission (HHSC).
The entities enter into this agreement FOR THE PURPOSE OF COLLABORATION in the Texas Healthcare
Transformation and Quality Improvement (1115 Transformation Waiver) Program.
STATEMENT OF SERVICES TO BE PERFORMED:
The City of Lubbock Health Department in collaboration with StarCare will utilize funds received from the
1115 Transformation Waiver Program to open a new indigent dental clinic (Dental Project) in Lubbock, Texas.
The goal of the Dental Project is to establish a new dental clinic, to provide routine and urgent dental services to
people who would not otherwise receive them and to avoid exacerbation of health problems.
City of Lubbock/Dental Project
Letter of Agreement
OBLIGATIONS OF THE CITY OF LUBBOCK
• The City of Lubbock is an Intergovernmental Transfer (IGT) Entity in the Regional Healthcare
Partnership 12 —University Medical Center (RHP 12) and as such will provide the state match for the
1115 Transformation Waiver in order to receive supplemental DSRIP payments from HHSC through
the intergovernmental transfer process (See Exhibit B: DSRIP Pool - Funding Flow chart.)
• The City of Lubbock is also a Performing Provider in RHP 12 and agrees to perform as the fiscal agent
and receive DSRIP funds from HHSC through electronic transfer.
• The City of Lubbock agrees to work collaboratively with StarCare for the duration of the 1115
Transformation Waiver to ensure compliance with the milestones, metrics and outcomes as outlined in
the RHP 12 Plan submitted to HHSC, which is incorporated herein by reference. (See Exhibit C.)
• When DSRIP payments (inclusive of the Federal incentive payment and the City of Lubbock's
IGT/match portion) are made to the City of Lubbock, the City of Lubbock will retain its IGT/match
amount and send the Federal incentive payment to StarCare, in consideration of the obligations
undertaken by StarCare (in accordance with the terms attached as Exhibit A.) The City of Lubbock
agrees StarCare bears total financial burden or benefit associated with the Dental Project and is not
entitled to any financial benefit therefrom.
• The City of Lubbock agrees to follow the schedule for funds submission/receipt as outlined in the
HHSC 1115 Transformation Waiver Program Funding and Mechanics Protocol located at
http://www.hhsc.state.tx.us/1115-docs/TX-DSRIP-Protocol-Approval.pdf which is incorporated herein,
by this reference. At the time of this writing the IGT/Incentive Payment for DSRIP Year 1 is scheduled
to be: IGT submission on May 14, 2013, with IGT return and Incentive Payment receipt approximately
June 30, 2013. For DSRIP Years 2-5, the IGT/Incentive Payments are estimated to occur on a quarterly
or semi-annual basis.
OBLIGATIONS OF STARCARE SPECIALTY HEALTH SYSTEM
• StarCare agrees to either provide directly or sub -contract for all aspects of the Dental Project, as
outlined in the RHP 12 Plana StarCare agrees that anywhere written in the RHP 12 Plan that the City of
Lubbock Health Department will provide, hire, train, etc. it is assumed to mean that the City of
Lubbock has engaged StarCare to provide, hire, train, etc. either directly or through sub -contract.
• StarCare agrees to accept the entire, Federal portion of funds received by the City of Lubbock for the
Dental Project as payment in full for its obligations under this Letter of Agreement; StarCare agrees the
City of Lubbock bears no additional financial burden for the Dental Project.
• Unless in the case of negligence or error on the part of the City of Lubbock, StarCare agrees it bears
total financial burden or benefit associated with the Dental Project and will not seek to share any
financial burden with the City of Lubbock.
• StarCare agrees to work collaboratively with the City of Lubbock for the duration of the 1115
Transformation Waiver to ensure compliance with the milestones, metrics and outcomes as outlined in
the RHP 12 Plan submitted to HHSC, which is incorporated herein by reference.
THE UNDERSIGNED AGENCIES have read this Letter of Agreement and by signing agree to all the terms
and provisions made between StarCare and the City of Lubbock as outlined.
City of Lubbock/Dental Project
Letter of Agreement
TERM AND TERMINATION
This Agreement is effective May 9, 2013 and is automatically renewable on a yearly basis upon mutual
agreement and acceptable performance. Any amendments to the terms of the agreement will be made in
writing and agreed upon by both agencies prior to implementation of changes.
Both agencies mutually agree that either agency may terminate this agreement with ninety (90) day written
notice.
Each entity is a Governmental Entity and hereby understands that any liability arising from this Agreement shall
be home by the responsible entity. Each entity shall be responsible for its own defense and resolution of any
claim against that entity.
THE UNDERSIGNVAG CIES have read this Letter of Agreement and by signing agree to all the terms
and provisions ad etwee 5 arCare and the City of Lubbock as outlined.
StarCare Sp t ' altb ystem: City of Lubb k:
Cathy Pope Date Gle . obe t Date
Chief Executive Officer Mayor
Approved as to Form:
Chad Weaver Date
Assistant City Attorney
Approved as to Content:
V Y1
Scott Snider Date
Assistant City Manager
Attest:
Bec Garza Date
City ecretary
City of Lubbock/Dental Project
Letter of Agreement
EXHIBIT A
FUNDS TRANSFER
1) The City of Lubbock agrees to transfer to StarCare the entire Federal portion of funds received from the 1115
Transformation Waiver/Dental Project. While the exact dates of receipt and exact amounts of funding are
yet to be determined good faith estimates are as follows:
DSRIP Year (DY)
Federal Portion of Funds
(to be transferred in full from the City
of Lubbock to StarCare)
State Portion of Funds
(to be used as IGT to draw down
Federal Funds
1
251,080
172,326
2
1,371,959
984,549
3
1,581,843
1,135,167
4
1,681,787
1,206,888
5
1,819,434
1,305,668
Total
$6,455,023
$4,632,272
Exact dates and amounts will be given to the City of Lubbock and StarCare from RHP 12. DY1 funds are expected to
be paid in one, lump sum; DY2-5 funds are expected to be paid quarterly or semi-annually.*
2) Upon receipt of funds, the City of Lubbock will transfer the Federal Portion, in full, electronically to StarCare.
StarCare will ensure the City of Lubbock is given all information necessary to make the electronic funds transfer.
*NOTE: In the HHSC 1115 Transformation Waiver Program Funding and Payment Protocol, payment for partial
milestone, metric and outcome achievement is possible. For example, if actual performance is 95% of planned
performance, then only 95% of the IGT shown above will be needed to draw down 95% of the incentive payment.
htip://www.hhsc.state.tx.us/1115-docs/TX-DSRIP-Protocol-Approval.pdf
City of Lubbock/Dental Project
Letter of Agreement
EXHIBIT B - DSRIP Pool - Funding Flow
DSRIP Pool — Funding Flow
• Public Hospital
• In areas with no public hospital:
• Hospital District
• Hospital Authority
• County
• State University with HSC or medical school
rR..P
Admtrativeinls
-RepoNng
C
Functions
l
O
0
Performing Provided
Reports performance'.
i
Examples
Exams
Public Hospital ---------------
Public Hospital
Public Hospital ------------
- Private Hospital
Public Hospital --------
---- Private Hospital ------------ Clinic
LMHA
LMHA
u
0
0
fGT Entity
c
Ides IGT to State
a
LL
Qd5
Approves federal
matchandsendsw
HHSC
n
e
m
E
m
6
L Performing
Performing Provider i bcanMiLuVaRor
Receives payments
Draft as of 04/02/12
EXHIBIT C
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan
Project Option: 1.8.6 - The expansion of existing dental clinics, the establishment of additional dental clinics or the expansion of dental clinic hours.
Performing Provider: City of Lubbock Health Department/135103304.1.1
Unique Project ID. 135103304.1.1
PROVIDER: The City of Lubbock, Texas is currently home to over 229,000 residents. The City of Lubbock Health Department's mission is to protect the health, safety
and welfare of citizens through: 1. Preventing epidemics and the spread of disease; 2. Educating and empowering people to adopt health and responsible
behaviors; 3. Promoting the quality and accessibility of health services; and 4. Developing new Insights and Innovative solutions to health problems.
INTERVENTIONS: The City of Lubbock Health Department will expand dental services, through the establishment of a new dental clinic.
NEED FOR THE PROJECT, The City of Lubbock selected this project because it directly addresses Region 12 Community Needs Assessment ID# CN13 (Important
Need): there Is a shortage of dental care, and IN CN3 (Urgent Need): Poor Insurance support or uninsured. The City of Lubbock does not currently operate a dental
clinic; therefore, this will be a new endeavor.
TARGET POPULATION: The target population for this project includes people who don't historically have access to or avail themselves of dental care: people with
mental illness, substance abuse Issues, intellectual disabilities, people who are homeless, people struggling with the challenges of aging, veterans, people living In
poverty, etc. Estimates are that 95% of the people served in this new clinic will be Medicaid funded or Indigent.
CATEGORY 1 EXPECTED PATIENT BENEFITS: During DY3 the City of Lubbock will hire and train staff, develop all operational protocols and clinical guidelines and
develop a baseline from which to calculate system improvements. The City of Lubbock hopes to provide at least 600 office visits during DY4 and to provide at least
750 office visits In DY5. Conceivably, over 350 people per year could be impacted by this project. The City of Lubbock will focus upon special needs patients, pregnant
women and/or the elderly hoping for a 1096 increase over baseline in OY4 and 15% over baseline In DY5.
CATEGORY 3 OUTCOMES: (IT — 7.7)The goal of this project is to decrease the number of older adults 65 years or older with urgent dental care needs by 10% from
baseline In DY4 and 15% from baseline In DY5.
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 1 of 26
Project Option: 1.8.6 - The expansion of existing dental clinics, the establishment of additional dental clinics or the expansion of dental clinic hours.
Performing Provider: City of Lubbock Health Department/135103304.1.1
Unique Project ID: 135103304.1.1
Project Description:
Dental health is a key component of overall health. Oral disease can lead to poor nutrition; serious systemic Illnesses and conditions such as poor birth outcomes,
diabetes and cardiovascular disease; and a diminished quality of life and life expectancy. Inadequate access to oral health services compounds other health issues.
can result In untreated dental disease that not only affects the mouth, but can also have physical, mental, economic and social consequences. Fortunately, many of
the adverse effects associated with poor oral health can be prevented with quality regular dental care, both at home and professionally. Increasing, expanding and
enhancing oral health services will Improve health outcomes.
The Texas Dental Association (TDA) looked carefully at the economic, medical and social consequences of untreated oral disease in Texas. It reviewed the current
systems of oral health care delivery, assessed payment structures, and studied the oral health status of Texans in general and analyzed the oral health disparities that
exist In the state. Then TDA made specific and practical policy recommendations to expand access to oral health care In Texas, Including: Identifying a "dental home"
for every citizen; creating new programs to encourage general dentists and specialists to practice In underserved areas and to treat underserved populations;
developing a comprehensive oral health public awareness and education campaign; and expanding access to oral health services for older citizens.
This project focuses upon all of these state priorities by establishing a new dental clinic, targeting people who don't historically have access to or avail themselves of
dental care: people with mental Illness, substance abuse issues, intellectual disabilities, people who are homeless, people struggling with the challenges of aging,
veterans, people living in poverty, etc. The City of Lubbock Health Department (City of Lubbock) does not have adequate resources to meet the demand for dental
services in Lubbock, especially for populations with special needs. This project sets forth collaboration with the Local Mental Health Authority (StarCare Specialty
Health System "StarCare") and a Federally Qualified Health Center (the Texas Tech School of Nursing's Federally Qualified Health Center, The Larry Combest Center
for Health and Wellness "Combest") to obtain synergy, economies of scale and to increase access for preventative dental visits impacting the severity of going to the
dentist as a last resort. This project will help divert patients from more expensive, less effective treatment of extreme dental procedures.
In the first stage of this project, the City of Lubbock will partner with StarCare and Combest to engage a Lubbock Oral Health Project Coordinator to conduct a city-
wide needs assessment related to citizens of all ages, to perform a gap analysis and to develop a dental coalition of all providers of dental services to people with low
income. In addition, the coalition will develop a Lubbock Oral Health Plan and begin Implementation of the Lubbock Oral Health Program. Next, the City of Lubbock,
StarCare and Combest will partner to open a new dental clinic, to Include the development of policies and procedures and hiring and training staff. The initial plan Is
to co -locate with a new integrated physical and behavioral health clinic In StarCare's Psychiatric Emergency Service Center in order to improve access to marginalized
populations. The City of Lubbock hopes to provide at least 600 office visits during DY4 and to provide at least 750 office visits In DY5. Conceivably, over 350 people
per year could be impacted by this project. The City of Lubbock will focus upon special needs patients, pregnant women and/or the elderly hoping for a 10% increase
over baseline in DY4 and 15% over baseline in DYS.
Goal of Project: The primary goals of this project are to: close gaps/disparities in access to dental care services and to enhance the quality of dental care provided.
Challenges: Challenges associated with the successful Implementation of this project are: lack of qualified dental providers, patient transportation and low oral
health literacy. The City of Lubbock will work with its project partners to develop and implement a comprehensive provider recruitment effort and public information
campaign. The dental clinic will likely provide bus passes to patients to help address issues related to transportation.
S -Year Expected Outcome for Performing Provider and Patients: Performing Provider Perspective — improved healthcare Infrastructure that better serves the
Medicaid -funded and uninsured residents of our counties; coordinated care delivery system; improved efficiency and cost growth containment.
• Patient Perspective — high quality, patient -centered care; improved access to coordinated healthcare; improved health outcomes.
Relationship to Regional Goals: Commissioned by the Regional Healthcare Partnership (RHP), the West Texas Area Health Education Center conducted an
assessment of the healthcare -related needs in Region 12. The resulting document ranked the needs in tiers, according to the availability of evidence documenting
each need. Tier one included the two (2) most pressing needs in RHP 12:1) a severe lack of primary care access including provider shortages, financial barriers, wait
times, and length of time to get an appointment; and 2) a lack of mental health services including lack of available appointments, insurance coverage, and emergency
room usage for mental health issues. Tier two Identified other priority Issues as: 1) uninsured and underinsured; 2) high incidence of obesity, diabetes, and heart
disease; 3) need for specialty care; and 4) need for cancer screenings; and 5) insufficient maternal and prenatal care. The goals of Region 12 are to address as many
identified community needs as possible, focusing on those Identified as "critical" and "urgent," including increased access to care, increased prevention and early
detection activities and quality/performance Improvement.
This project is directly related to the Region 12 goals of increased access to care and increased prevention and early detection activities. This project will transform
healthcare delivery from a disease -focused model of episodic care to a patient centered, coordinated delivery model that Improves patient satisfaction and health
outcomes, reduces unnecessary or duplicative services and builds on the accomplishments of our existing healthcare system.
Starting Point/Baseline: The City of Lubbock does not currently operate a dental clinic; therefore, the starting point/baseline for the number of people to be assisted
is zero.
Reason/Rationale for Selecting Measure: Poor oral health affects more than just the mouth. It can seriously compromise a person's general health, quality of fife and
life expectancy. Oral diseases can and do lead to systemic problems — damaging other parts of the body and resulting in the need for expensive emergency
department visits, hospital stays and medications. The consequences of poor oral health, however, go for beyond damaging medical effects. oral disease can also
wreak economic havoc — keeping children out of school and adults home from work — not to mention lower productivity of workers in pain. Untreated oral diseases
can also drive up heaith care costs in general. The good news is that with proper oml healthcare, both at home and in professional settings, many of the negative
consequences associated with poor oral health can be prevented.'
htt::7wwtiv.buildin«hetteroralheahh.or* m • iaiTDA fall re ort. df
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan
Page 2 of 26
The number of emergency -room visits for patients seeking dental treatment has Increased, mostly because of problems that could have been prevented with regular
dental visits, according to the Pew Center on the States. Most cases are in rural areas, which have a shortage of dentists. Nationwide, the number of ER dental visits
increased 16 percent from 2006 to 2009, and the center suggests the trend is continuing. Visiting the ER for dental treatment can be 10 times more expensive than
preventive care. Many visits Involve the same patients seeking more care because emergency rooms aren't staffed by dentists. Doctors can offer pain relief, but not
much more, and many patients can't afford follow-up treatment or can't find a dentist. "Emergency rooms are really the canary in the coal mine. If people are
showing up in the ER for dental care, then we've got big holes In the delivery of care," said Shelly Gehshan, director of Pew's chlld-dentistry campaign. 'it's Just like
pouring money down a hole." The Center analyzed information from 24 states, the Federal Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality and dental care studies. It
found that in 2009, 56 percent of children with Medicaid didn't receive dental care, ER visits for dental care increased by almost 60 percent In South Carolina, and
there were 55,000 dental -related ER visits in Tennessee hospitals. Part of the problem Is that few dentists participate In Medicaid programs, The Associated Press
reports. The center is working with states to develop dental hygienists training programs and train non -dentists to treat cavities and other uncomplicated procedures.
More than 830,000 visits to emergency rooms nationwide In 2009 were for preventable dental problems. Dental disease Is the No. i chronic childhood disease,
sending more children In search of medical treatment than asthma. In a nation obsessed with high-tech medicine, people are not getting preventive care for
something as simple as tooth decay. 2
The following Project Option and Project Components were selected because they directly address Region 12 Community Needs Assessment IDN CN13 (important
Need): There is a shortage of dental care; and IDN CN3 (Urgent Need): Poor Insurance support or uninsured.
Project Option 1.8: Increase and expand services by increasing clinics, clinic hours, using satellite mobile clinics with an affiliated fixed -site dental clinic location,
school-based/school-linked health centers or other approaches to increase oral health services to underserved populations. Project Component: 1.8.6 Establish a
new dental clinic.
The City of Lubbock will conduct Continuous Quality Improvement (CQI) activities using methods such as rapid cycle Improvement. Activities may Include, but are not
limited to, identifying project impacts, identifying "lessons learned," opportunities to scale all or part of the project to a broader patient population and identifying
key challenges associated with expansion of the project, including special considerations for safety -net populations. Our RHP will encourage participation by all our
partners In a Leaming Collaborative that will meet annually to discuss local disparities In care and the ways they have successfully gathered relevant data and
ultimately better served the populations In their projects. In addition to the face-to-face meeting, we will have an open forum on our website that will foster
communication amongst our partners with related projects.
Unique Community Need IDN: CN13 There is a shortage of dental services and CN3 Poor insurance support or uninsured.
Milestones & Metria: The milestones and metrics (1.8.6— P-4,4.1; P-10,10.1; and 1.14,14.1) selected for this project directly address CNN13&3 outlined In the
Region 12 Community Needs Assessment.
Related Category 3 Outcome Measure: OD -7 Oral Health; IT -7.7 Urgent Dental Care Needs in Older Adults: Proportion of older adults aged 65 and older with urgent
dental care needs (standalone measure)
Reason/Rationale for Selection: According to the Region 12 Community Needs Assessment, there Is a shortage of dental services and a high prevalence of people
with poor insurance support or who are uninsured. According to the TDA, services for older Texans is a priority.
Explanation of how focusing on the outcomes will help Improve the health of low -Income populations: Establishment of a new dental clinic focusing services upon
people who are under- or uninsured will directly help Improve the health of low -Income populations.
Relationship to Other Projects: This project relates to the City of Lubbocles Pass 2 project (135103304.1.2 — expand access/hours in dental clinic) in that it is the
foundation project that opens a new dental clinic. These projects are all related in that they are aimed to increasing access to needed health care in the most
appropriate setting.
Relationship to Other Performing Providers' Projects in RHP & Plan for teaming Collaborative: This project relates to StarCare's Pass 1 and Pass 2 projects
(084897001.1.1 and 084897001.1.2) - to open a Psychiatric Emergency Service Center and adolescent crisis respite unit — In that this clinic will be housed within the
same facility. Our RHP will encourage participation by all our partners in a "teaming collaborative" that will meet annually to discuss local disparities in care and the
ways they have successfully gathered relevant data and ultimately better served the populations in their projects. In addition to the face-to-face meeting, we will
have an open forum on our website that will foster communication amongst Project Option: 1.8.6 - The expansion of existing dental clinics, the establishment of
additional dental clinics or the expansion of dental clinic hours.
Performing Provider. City of Lubbock Health Department/135103304.1.1
Unique Project ID: 135303304.1.1
PROVIDER: The city of Lubbock, Texas is currently home to over 229,000 residents. The City of Lubbock Health Department's mission is to protect the health, safety
and welfare of citizens through: 1. Preventing epidemics and the spread of disease; 2. Educating and empowering people to adopt health and responsible
behaviors; 3. Promoting the quality and accessibility of health services; and 4. Developing new Insights and innovative solutions to health problems.
INTERVENTIONS: The City of Lubbock Health Department will expand dental services, through the establishment of a new dental clinic.
NEED FOR THE PROJECT, The City of Lubbock selected this project because it directly addresses Region 12 Community Needs Assessment IDN CN23 (Important
Need): There is a shortage of dental care,, and IDN CN3 (Urgent Need): Poor Insurance support or uninsured. The City of Lubbock does not currently operate a dental
clinic; therefore, this will be a new endeavor.
httnahvwH'.peHstates.ore/uploadeffile%TCS A,,setsi20l2!A ,;2OCostly o2ODciitall'2ODcstination(l ).pdf
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 3 of 26
TARGET POPULATION: The target population for this project Includes people who don't historically have access to or avail themselves of dental care: people with
mental illness, substance abuse Issues, intellectual disabilities, people who are homeless, people struggling with the challenges of aging, veterans, people living in
poverty, etc. Estimates are that 95% of the people served In this new clinic will be Medicaid funded or indigent.
CATEGORY 1 EXPECTED PATIENT BENEFITS: During DY3 the City of Lubbock will hire and train staff, develop all operational protocols and clinical guidelines and
develop a baseline from which to calculate system improvements. The City of Lubbock hopes to provide at least 600 office visits during DY4 and to provide at least
750 office visits in DYS. Conceivably, over 350 people per year could be impacted by this project. The City of Lubbock will focus upon special needs patients, pregnant
women and/or the elderly hoping for a 10% increase over baseline in DY4 and 1596 over baseline In DY5.
CATEGORY 3 OUTCOMES: (IT — 7.7)The goal of this project is to decrease the number of older adults 65 years or older with urgent dental care needs by 10% from
baseline in DY4 and 15% from baseline in DY5.
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 4 of 26
Project Option: 1.8.6 - The expansion of existing dental clinics, the establishment of additional dental clinics or the expansion of dental clinic hours.
Performing Provider: City of Lubbock Health Department/135103304.1.1
Unique Project ID: 135103304.1.1
Project Description:
Dental health is a key component of overall health. Oral disease can lead to poor nutrition; serious systemic illnesses and conditions such as poor birth outcomes,
diabetes and cardiovascular disease; and a diminished quality of life and life expectancy. Inadequate access to oral health services compounds other health issues.
can result in untreated dental disease that not only affects the mouth, but can also have physical, mental, economic and social consequences. Fortunately, many of
the adverse effects associated with poor oral health can be prevented with quality regular dental care, both at home and professionally. Increasing, expanding and
enhancing oral health services will improve health outcomes.
The Texas Dental Association (TDA) looked carefully at the economic, medical and social consequences of untreated oral disease in Texas. It reviewed the current
systems of oral health care delivery, assessed payment structures, and studied the oral health status of Texans in general and analyzed the oral health disparities that
exist In the state. Then TDA made specific and practical policy recommendations to expand access to oral health care in Texas, including: identifying a "dental home"
for every citizen; creating new programs to encourage general dentists and specialists to practice In underserved areas and to treat underserved populations;
developing a comprehensive oral health public awareness and education campaign; and expanding access to oral health services for older citizens.
This project focuses upon all of these state priorities by establishing a new dental clinic, targeting people who don't historically have access to or avail themselves of
dental care: people with mental Illness, substance abuse issues, intellectual disabilities, people who are homeless, people struggling with the challenges of aging,
veterans, people living in poverty, etc. The City of Lubbock Health Department (City of Lubbock) does not have adequate resources to meet the demand for dental
services in Lubbock, especially for populations with special needs. This project sets forth collaboration with the Local Mental Health Authority (StarCare Specialty
Health System "StarCare") and a Federally Qualified Health Center (the Texas Tech School of Nursing's Federally Qualified Health Center, The Larry Combest Center
for Health and Wellness "Combest") to obtain synergy, economies of scale and to increase access for preventative dental visits impacting the severity of going to the
dentist as a last resort. This project will help divert patients from more expensive, less effective treatment of extreme dental procedures.
In the first stage of this project, the City of Lubbock will partner with StarCare and Combest to engage a Lubbock Oral Health Project Coordinator to conduct a city-
wide needs assessment related to citizens of all ages, to perform a gap analysis and to develop a dental coalition of all providers of dental services to people with low
income. In addition, the coalition will develop a Lubbock Oral Health Plan and begin implementation of the Lubbock Oral Health Program. Next, the City of Lubbock,
StarCare and Combest will partner to open a new dental clinic, to include the development of policies and procedures and hiring and training staff. The initial plan is
to co -locate with a new Integrated physical and behavioral health clinic in StarCare's Psychiatric Emergency Service Center In order to Improve access to marginalized
populations. The City of Lubbock hopes to provide at least 600 office visits during DY4 and to provide at least 750 office visits in DYS. Conceivably, over 350 people
per year could be impacted by this project. The City of Lubbock will focus upon special needs patients, pregnant women and/or the elderly hoping for a 10% increase
over baseline in DY4 and 15% over baseline in DYS.
Goal of Project: The primary goals of this project are to: close Saps/disparities in access to dental care services and to enhance the quality of dental care provided.
Challenges: Challenges associated with the successful implementation of this project are: lack of qualified dental providers, patient transportation and low oral
health literacy. The City of Lubbock will work with its project partners to develop and implement a comprehensive provider recruitment effort and public information
campaign. The dental clinic will likely provide bus passes to patients to help address Issues related to transportation.
S -Year Expected Outcome for Performing Provider and Patients: Performing Provider Perspective — Improved healthcare Infrastructure that better serves the
Medicaid -funded and uninsured residents of our counties; coordinated care delivery system; improved efficiency and cost growth containment.
• Patient Perspective— high quality, patient -centered care; improved access to coordinated healthcare; improved health outcomes.
Relationship to Regional Goals: Commissioned by the Regional Healthcare Partnership (RHP), the West Texas Area Health Education Center conducted an
assessment of the healthcare -related needs In Region 12. The resulting document ranked the needs In tiers, according to the availability of evidence documenting
each need. Tier one included the two (2) most pressing needs in RHP 12:1) a severe lack of primary care access including provider shortages, financial barriers, wait
times, and length of time to get an appointment; and 2) a lack of mental health services including lack of available appointments, insurance coverage, and emergency
room usage for mental health issues. Tier two Identified other priority issues as: 1) uninsured and underinsured; 2) high incidence of obesity, diabetes, and heart
disease; 3) need for specialty care; and 4) need for cancer screenings; and 5) insufficient maternal and prenatal care. The goals of Region 12 are to address as many
Identified community needs as possible, focusing on those identified as "critical" and "urgent," Including Increased access to care, increased prevention and early
detection activities and quality/performance Improvement.
This project is directly related to the Region 12 goals of increased access to care and increased prevention and early detection activities. This project will transform
healthcare delivery from a disease -focused model of episodic care to a patient centered, coordinated delivery model that improves patient satisfaction and health
outcomes, reduces unnecessary or duplicative services and builds on the accomplishments of our existing healthcare system.
Starting Point/Baseline: The City of Lubbock does not currently operate a dental clinic; therefore, the starting point/baseline for the number of people to be assisted
is zero.
Reason/Rationale for Selecting Measure: Poor oral health affects more than Just the mouth. It can seriously compromise a person's general health, quality of live and
life expectancy. oral diseases can and do lead to systemic problems — damaging other parts of the body and resulting in the need for expensive emergency
department visits, hospital stays and medications. The consequences of poor oral health, however, go for beyond damaging medical effects. oral disease con also
wreak economic havoc —keeping children out of school and adults home from work —not to mention lower productivity of workers in pain. Untreated oral diseases
can also drive up health care costs in general. The good news is that with proper oral health care, both at home and in professional settings, many of the negative
consequences associated with poor oral health can be prevented.'
3 httn:Hwww.buildingbetteioralhcalth.or,, inedia/'T'DA full report.ndf
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan
Page 5 of 26
The number of emergency -room visits for patients seeking dental treatment has Increased, mostly because of problems that could have been prevented with regular
dental visits, according to the Pew Center on the States. Most cases are in rural areas, which have a shortage of dentists. Nationwide, the number of ER dental visits
increased 16 percent from 2006 to 1009, and the center suggests the trend is continuing. Visiting the ER for dental treatment can be 10 times more expensive than
preventive care. Many visits involve the same patients seeking more care because emergency rooms aren't staffed by dentists. Doctors can offer pain relief, but not
much more, and many patients can't afford follow-up treatment or can't find a dentist. "Emergency rooms are really the canary In the coal mine. If people are
showing up in the ER for dental care, then we've got big holes In the delivery of care," said Shelly Gehshan, director of Pew's child -dentistry campaign. "It's just like
pouring money down a hole." The Center analyzed Information from 24 states, the Federal Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality and dental care studies. It
found that in 2009, 56 percent of children with Medicaid didn't receive dental care, ER visits for dental care increased by almost 60 percent in South Carolina, and
there were 55,000 dental -related ER visits to Tennessee hospitals. Part of the problem is that few dentists participate in Medicaid programs, The Associated Press
reports. The center is working with states to develop dental hygienists training programs and train non -dentists to treat cavities and other uncomplicated procedures.
More than 830,000 visits to emergency rooms nationwide In 2009 were for preventable dental problems. Dental disease Is the No.1 chronic childhood disease,
sending more children In search of medical treatment than asthma. In a nation obsessed with high-tech medicine, people are not getting preventive care for
something as simple as tooth decay.'
The following Project Option and Project Components were selected because they directly address Region 12 Community Needs Assessment ID# CN13 (Important
Need): There is a shortage of dental care, and ID# CN3 (Urgent Need): Poor insurance support or uninsured.
Project Option 1.8: increase and expand services by increasing clinics, clinic hours, using satellite mobile clinics with an affiliated fixed -site dental clinic location,
school-based/school-Ilnked health centers or other approaches to increase oral health services to underserved populations. Project Component: 1.8.6 Establish a
new dental clinic.
The City of Lubbock will conduct Continuous Quality Improvement (CQI) activities using methods such as rapid cycle Improvement. Activities may include, but are not
limited to, identifying project Impacts, Identifying "lessons learned," opportunities to scale all or part of the project to a broader patient population and identifying
key challenges associated with expansion of the project, Including special considerations for safety -net populations. Our RHP will encourage participation by all our
partners In a Learning Collaborative that will meet annually to discuss local disparities in pre and the ways they have successfully gathered relevant data and
ultimately better served the populations in their projects. In addition to the face-to-face meeting, we will have an open forum on our website that will foster
communication amongst our partners with related projects.
Unique Community Need IDN: CN13 There is a shortage of dental services and CN3 Poor Insurance support or uninsured.
Milestones & Metria: The milestones and metria (1.8.6 — P-4, 4.1; P-10,10.1; and 1-14, 14.1) selected for this project directly address CN#13&3 outlined in the
Region 12 Community Needs Assessment.
Related Category 3 Outcome Measure: OD -7 Oral Health; IT -7.7 Urgent Dental Care Needs in Older Adults: Proportion of older adults aged 65 and older with urgent
dental care needs (standalone measure)
Reason/Rationale for Selection: According to the Region 12 Community Needs Assessment, there is a shortage of dental services and a high prevalence of people
with poor insurance support or who are uninsured. According to the TDA, services for older Texans Is a priority.
Explanation of how focusing on the outcomes will help Improve the health of lowdncome populations: Establishment of a new dental clinic focusing services upon
people who are under- or uninsured will directly help Improve the health of low -Income populations.
Relationship to Other Projects: This project relates to the City of Lubbock's Pass 2 project (135103304.1.2 — expand access/hours in dental clinic) in that it is the
foundation project that opens a new dental clinic. These projects are all related In that they are aimed to increasing access to needed health care in the most
appropriate setting.
Relationship to Other Performing Providers' Projects in RHP & Plan for learning Collaborative: This project relates to StarCaWs Pass 1 and Pass 2 projects
(084897001.1.1 and 084897001.1.2) - to open a Psychiatric Emergency Service Center and adolescent crisis respite unit — In that this clinic will be housed within the
same facility. Our RHP will encourage participation by all our partners in a "learning collaborative" that will meet annually to discuss local disparities in care and the
ways they have successfully gathered relevant data and ultimately better served the populations in their projects. In addition to the face-to-face meeting, we will
have an onpn fnrum on our wphtite that will foster rnmmunlratinn amnnast our nartners with relatpd nroiprts. Prolact Valuation:
Criteria
Narrative
Score
Achieves
This project is designed to achieve, to the greatest extent possible, the Texas Healthcare Transformation and Quality Improvement
Waiver
(1115 Waiver) goals of 1. Improved patient care experlence; 2. Improved health; and 3. Reduced cost of healthcare, without
Goals
compromised quality. In order to achieve alignment with this triple aim, the primary goal of this project Is to ensure people receive
Scale:
coordinated, timely and site -appropriate healthcare services. The City of Lubbock hopes to address the healthcare disparity of
s
1 to 5
unequal access for people with low-income. This project will transform healthcare delivery from a disease -focused model of episodic
5 Greatest
care to a patient centered, coordinated delivery model that Improves patient satisfaction and health outcomes, reduces unnecessary
or duplicative services and builds on the accomplishments of our existing healthcare system.
Addresses
Commissioned by the Regional Healthcare Partnership (RHP), the West Texas Area Health Education Center conducted an assessment
of the healthcare -related needs In Region 12. The goals of Region 12 are to address as many Identified community needs as possible,
Community
Need(s)
focusing on those Identified as "critical" and "urgent," including increased access to care, increased prevention and early detection
activities and quality/performance improvement. The following Project Option and Project Components were selected because they
S
Scale:
directly address Region 12 Community Needs Assessment ION CN13 (Important Need): There is a shortage of dental care, and ID# CN3
ito5
5 Greatest
(Urgent Need): Poor Insurance support or uninsured. The lack of available appointments for people without money or Insurance,
results in the need to use emergency rooms for initial contact.
blip:: �rw��.iic���tates.or uploadcdFilesiPC5 Assets/2012/..%'ko2OCostly4o2ODental°',20Des(ination( 1).pdf
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 6 of 26
Project
The City of Lubbock hopes to provide at least 600 office visits during DY4 and to provide at least 750 office visits in DYS.
Scope/Size
Conceivably, over 350 people per year could be Impacted by this project. The City of Lubbock will focus upon special needs patients,
pregnant women and/or the elderly hoping for a 1095 increase over baseline In DY4 and 15% over baseline in DYS. when considering
4
1 to 5
the impact upon each person's care experience, his/her health and the reduced cost upon the community's healthcare delivery
5 Greatest
system, the scope and size of this project will be fairly great. This project will be managed by highly trained staff who specialize In
linkage to the right care In the right setting.
Project
The City of Lubbock's investment In this project will be fairly significant. Staffing will include a Program Director, Dentist(s), Licensed
Investment
Hygienists, Dentals Technicians, office personnel, etc. (Some administrative staff will be shared with StarCare and Combest in order to
4
Scale:
obtain economies of scale.) Other investments include physical space, furnishings and equipment, computer hardware/software, etc.
1 to 5
As one might Imagine, dental equipment can be very expensive.
5 Greatest
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 7 of 26
135303304.1.1 1.8.6 n/a The expansion of existing dental ciinlcs, the establishment of
addlelonal dental clinics or the expansion of dental clinic boors.
tl of Lubbock Health De rtment 135103304
Related Category 30utcome 135103304.3.1 IT,]) Urgent Dental Care Need in Older Adults: Proportion of older
Measum(s): I I adults aged 65 and older with urgent dental care needs
Milestone 1:1P-101:
Participate in face-to-face
teaming Il, meetings or
seminars) at least twice per
year with other provitlers and
the RHP to promote
collaborative learning around
shared or similar projects. At
each face-to-face meeting. all
providers shall Identify and
agree upon several
Improvement (simple
Initiatives mat all providers
an do to "raise the floor for
performance.) Each
participating provider should
publicly commit to
Implementing these
Improvements.
McVic(s): IP -10.11
Panicipate in sembannual
(aceta face meetings or
seminars organized by the
PHP.
Baseline/Goal: Particlpate In
face-to-face meetings
Data Source: Documentation
of well annual meetings,
Including meeting agendas,
slides from presentations,
and/or meeting notes.
Milestone 1 Estimated
Incentive Payment:
$1,941,214
Participate In face to face learning I.e.
meetings or seminars) at least twice per
year with other providers antl the RHP to
promote collaborative learning around
shared or similar projects. At each face to.
face meeting, all providers shall Identify
and agree upon several Improvement
(simple Initiatives that all providers can do
to "raise the fWr for performance.) Each
Participating provider should publicly
commit to Implementing thew
Improvements.
Metric(,): IP -10.11
Participate In worbannual face-taface
meetings or seminars organized by the
RHP.
Baseline/Gwl: Participate In faceo-toface
meetings
Data Source: Documentation of send -
annual meetings, Including meeting
agendas, slides from presentations, and/or
meeting notes.
Milestone 3 Estimated Incentive Payment:
$1,066,396
Milestone 3: IP -31
Increase Interdisciplinary (IDTI training and
education for dental and other health care
providers to promote an 10 Team approach
to addressing oral health.
Metric(,): IP3.11
City of Lubbock will hold quarterly (4/year)
grand rounds, Imservlce tralnings and
continuing education that focus on oral
health Issues and Implications as related to
chronic diseases, such as diabetes and
cardiovascular disease and pregnancy.
Goal: City of Lubbock call I hold quarterly
(4/year) grand rountls, n-servlce comings
and continuing education that focus on oral
health Issues and Implications as related to
chronic diseases, such as diabetes and
cardiovascular disease and pregnancy.
Data Source: Attendance rosters, Power
point presentations, sign In sheets, etc.
Milestone 3 Estimated Incentive Payment:
$1,066,395
[itv of Lubbock Health Department - RHP
exating/reladte dental care clinics or
space.
Metak(sI: IP 4.11
Number of additional clinics. expanded
space, or existing available space used to
capacity.
8arellne/Goal: Add 1 new clime
Data Source: Tax IDN
Milestone 4 Estimated Incentive
Payment; 5760,530
Milestone S; JP -31
Increase lnterdlstlplmary(IDT)training
and education for dental and other
health care providers to promote an ID
Team approach to addressing oral health.
MetrMs): IP3.11
City of Lubbock will hold quarterly
(4/year) grand round , in-service
tralnings and continuing education that
(OCL'
on oral health issues and
Impllatlons as related to chronic
diseases, such as diabetes and
cardiovascular disease and pregnanry.
Goal: City of Lubbock will hold quarterly
(4/year) grand rounds, In-service
tralnings and continuing education that
focus on oral health Issues and
Implications as related to chronic
diseases, such as diabetes and
cardiovascular disease and pregnancy.
Data Source: Attendance rosters, power
point presentations, sign In sheets, etc.
Milestone 5 Estimated Incentive
Payment: $160,530
Milestone 6: 14141
Increase number of special population
members that access dental services
Metricls): 11-14.11
10% Increase over baseline In the number
of children, special needs patients,
pregnant women and/or the elderly
accessing dental services.
Goal: 10% Increase over baaMe In the
number of children, special needs
patients, pregnant women and/or the
elderly accessing dental services.
Data Soudan Claims, encounter and
members that access dental services
Metro): p-14.1)
15% Increase from baseline In the
number of children, special needs
patients, pregnant women and/or the
elderly accessing dental services.
Bauline/Goal: 1091increase over
baseline in the number of Children,
special needs patients, pregnant
women and/or the elderly accessing
dental seances.
Data Source: Claims, encounter and
clinical record dark
Milestone 6 Estimated Incentive
Payment: $1,101,118
Milestone 7: IP -31
Increase Interdisciplinary LDT) training
and education for dental and other
health are providers to promote an IO
Team approach to addressing out
health.
Metrift IP3.11
City of Lubbock will hold quarterly
(4/year) grand rounds, In service
trainings and continuing education
that focus on oral health issues and
Implications as related to chronic
diseases, such as diabetes and
cardiovascular disease and pregnanry.
Goal: City of Lubbock will bold
quarterly (4/year) grand rounds, in-
service tralnings and continuing
education that focus on oral health
Issues and implications as related to
chronic diseases, such as diabetes and
cardiovascular disease and pregnancy.
Data Source: Attendance rosters,
power point presentations, sign In
sheets, etc.
Milestone 7 Estimated Incentive
Payment:.$1,102,217
Pape 9 of 26
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 9 of 26
Milestone 6 Estimated Incentive
Payment: $760,530
DY 2 Estimated Milestone Bundle
DY 3 Estimated Milestone Bundle
DY4 Estimated Milestone Bundle
DY5 Estimated Milestone Bundle
Amount: $1,942,214
Amount: $2,132,791
Amount: $2,281,590
Amount: $2,204,435
TOTAL ESTIMATED INCENTIVE PAYMENTS FOR 4-YEAR PERIOD (add milestone bundle amounts over Years Z-5):$8,561,029
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 9 of 26
Project Option: 1.8.6 - The expansion of existing dental clinics, the establishment of additional dental clinics or the expansion of dental clinic hours. Performing
Provider: City of Lubbock Health Department/135103304
Unique Project ID: 135103304.1.2 — "PASS 2"
PROVIDER: The City of Lubbock, Texas is currently home to over 229,000 residents. The City of Lubbock Health Department's mission is to protect the health, safety
and welfare of citizens through: 1. Preventing epidemics and the spread of disease; 2. Educating and empowering people to adopt health and responsible
behaviors; 3. Promoting the quality and accessibility of health services; and 4. Developing new insights and Innovative solutions to health problems.
INTERVENTIONSThe City of Lubbock Health Department will expand dental services, through the establishment of a new dental clinic.
NEED FOR THE PROJECT: The City of Lubbock selected this project because It directly addresses Region 12 Community Needs Assessment IDA CN13 (Important
Need): There is a shortage of dental care,• and ID# CN3 (Urgent Need): Poor Insurance support or uninsured. The City of Lubbock does not currently operate a dental
clinic; therefore, this will be a new endeavor.
TARGET POPULATION: The target population for this project Includes people who don't historically have access to or avail themselves of dental care: people with
mental illness, substance abuse issues, intellectual disabilities, people who are homeless, people struggling with the challenges of aging, veterans, people living In
poverty, etc. Estimates are that 95% of the people served in this new clinic will be Medicaid funded or indigent.
CATEGORY 1 EXPECTED PATIENT BENEFITS: During DY3 the City of Lubbock will hire and train staff, develop all operational protocols and clinical guidelines and
develop a baseline from which to calculate system Improvements. With Pass 1 funding, the City of Lubbock plans to provide at least 600 office visits in DY4 and to
provide at least 750 office visits in DY5, serving 350 people per year. Pass 2 funding will allow the City of Lubbock to provide an additional 250 office visits each year
in DY4 and DYS, with capacity to serve 147 more people each year. The City of Lubbock will focus upon special needs patients, pregnant women and/or the elderly
hoping for a 10% increase over baseline in DY4 and 15% over baseline in DYS.
CATEGORY 3 OUTCOMES: (IT — 7.7) The goal of this project is to decrease of older adults 65 years or olderwith urgent dental care needsby 10% from baseline in DY4
and 15% from baseline In DYS.
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 10 of 26
Project Option: 1.8.6 - The expansion of existing dental clinics, the establishment of additional dental clinics or the expansion of dental clinic hours.
Performing Provider: City of Lubbock Health Department/135103304
Unique Project ID: 135103304.1.2 - "PASS 2"
Project Description: During Pass 2, the City of Lubbock will expand Its Pass 1 project (which was to establish a new dental clinic) in two (2) ways: 1. Serve more
people than possible with Pass 1 funding alone and 2. Expand dental clinic hours from those anticipated with Pass 1 funding.
Dental health is a key component of overall health. Oral disease can lead to poor nutrition; serious systemic Illnesses and conditions such as poor birth outcomes,
diabetes and cardiovascular disease; and a diminished quality of life and life expectancy. Inadequate access to oral health services compounds other health Issues.
can result in untreated dental disease that not only affects the mouth, but can also have physical, mental, economic and social consequences. Fortunately, many of
the adverse effects associated with poor oral health can be prevented with quality regular dental care, both at home and professionally. Increasing, expanding and
enhancing oral health services will Improve health outcomes.
The Texas Dental Association (TDA) looked carefully at the economic, medical and social consequences of untreated oral disease in Texas. It reviewed the current
systems of oral health care delivery, assessed payment structures, and studied the oral health status of Texans in general and analyzed the oral health disparities that
exist in the state. Then TDA made specific and practical policy recommendations to expand access to oral health care in Texas, including: Identifying a "dental home"
for every citizen; creating new programs to encourage general dentists and specialists to practice In underserved areas and to treat underserved populations;
developing a comprehensive oral health public awareness and education campaign; and expanding access to oral health services for older citizens.
This project (in combination with the City of Lubbock's Pass 1 project) focuses upon all of these state priorities by establishing a new dental clinic, targeting people
who don't historically have access to or avail themselves of dental care: people with mental Illness, substance abuse Issues, Intellectual disabilities, people who are
homeless, people struggling with the challenges of aging, veterans, people living In poverty, etc. The City of Lubbock Health Department (City of Lubbock) does not
have adequate resources to meet the demand for dental services in Lubbock, especially for populations with special needs. This project sets forth collaboration with
the Local Mental Health Authority (StarCare Specialty Health System "StarCare") and a Federally Qualified Health Center (the Texas Tech School of Nursing's Federally
Qualified Health Center, The Larry Combest Center for Health and Wellness "Combese) to obtain synergy, economies of scale and to increase access for preventative
dental visits impacting the severity of going to the dentist as a last resort. This project will help divert patients from more expensive, less effective treatment of
extreme dental procedures.
The City of Lubbock plans to partner with StarCare and Combest to engage a Lubbock Oral Health Project Coordinator to conduct a city-wide needs assessment
related to citizens of all ages, to perform a gap analysis and to develop a dental coalition of all providers of dental services to people with low Income. In addition, the
coalition will develop a Lubbock Oral Health Plan and begin implementation of the Lubbock Oral Health Program. Next, the City of Lubbock, StarCare and Combest
will partner to open a new dental clinic, to Include the development of policies and procedures and hiring and training staff. The initial plan Is to co -locate with a new
integrated physical and behavioral health clinic in StarCare's Psychiatric Emergency Service Center in order to improve access to marginalized populations. With Pass
1 funding, the City of Lubbock plans to provide at least 600 office visits in DY4 and to provide at least 750 office visits In DYS, serving 350 people per year. Pass 2
funding will allow the City of Lubbock to provide an additional 2S0 office visits each year In DY4 and DYS, with capacity to serve 147 more people each year. The City
of Lubbock will focus upon special needs patients, pregnant women and/or the elderly hoping for a 10% Increase over baseline in DY4 and 1S% over baseline in DYS.
Goal of Project: The primary goals of this project are to: close gaps/disparities In access to dental care services and to enhance the quality of dental care provided.
Challenges: Challenges associated with the successful implementation of this project are: lack of qualified dental providers, patient transportation and
low oral health literacy. The City of Lubbock will work with its project partners to develop and implement a comprehensive provider recruitment effort and public
Information campaign. The dental clinic will likely provide bus passes to patients to help address Issues related to transportation.
5 -Year Expected Outcome for Performing Provider and Patients: Performing Provider Perspective —Improved healthcare Infrastructure that better serves the
Medicaid -funded and uninsured residents of our counties; coordinated care delivery system; improved efficiency and cost growth containment.
• Patient Perspective— high quality, patient -centered care; improved access to coordinated healthcare; improved health outcomes.
Relationship to Regional Goals: Commissioned by the Regional Healthcare Partnership (RHP), the West Texas Area Health Education Center conducted an
assessment of the healthcare -related needs In Region 12. The resulting document ranked the needs In tiers, according to the availability of evidence documenting
each need. Tier one Included the two (2) most pressing needs in RHP 12:1) a severe lack of primary care access including provider shortages, financial barriers, wait
times, and length of time to get an appointment; and 2) a lack of mental health services including lack of available appointments, insurance coverage, and emergency
room usage for mental health issues. Tier two Identified other priority issues as: 1) uninsured and undertnsured; 2) high Incidence of obesity, diabetes, and heart
disease, 3) need for specialty care; and 4) need for cancer screenings; and S) Insufficient matemal and prenatal care. The goals of Region 12 are to address as many
Identified community needs as possible, focusing on those identified as "critical" and 'urgent," including Increased access to care, increased prevention and early
detection activities and quality/performance Improvement.
This project is directly related to the Region 12 goals of increased access to care and Increased prevention and early detection activities. This project will transform
healthcare delivery from a disease -focused model of episodic care to a patient centered, coordinated delivery model that Improves patient satisfaction and health
outcomes, reduces unnecessary or duplicative services and builds on the accomplishments of our existing healthcare system.
Starting Point/Baseline: The City of Lubbock does not currently operate a dental clinic; therefore, the starting point/baseline for the number of people to be assisted
is zero.
Reason/Rationale for Selecting Measure: Poor oral health affects more than just the mouth. It can seriously compromise a person's general health, quality of fife and
fife expectancy. Oral diseases can and do lead to systemic problems — damaging other parts of the body and resulting /n the need for expensive emergency
department visits, hospital stays and medications. The consequences of poor aro/ health, however, go for beyond damaging medical effects. Oral disease can also
wreak economic havoc — keeping children out of school and adults home from work — not to mention lower productivity of workers in pain. Untreated oral diseases
can also drive up healthcare costs /a general. The good news is that with proper oro/ healthcare, both at home and in professional settings, many of the negative
consequences associated with poor oral health can be prevented.'
S littn://www.buildingbeuemrallicalth.or,,Jtnedia/-rDA full report.ndf
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 11 of 26
The number of emergency -room visits for patients seeking dental treatment has Increased, mostly because of problems that could have been prevented with regular
dental visits, according to the Pew Center on the States. Most cases are in rural areas, which have a shortage of dentists. Nationwide, the number of ER dental visits
increased 16 percent from 2006 to 2009, and the center suggests the trend is continuing. Visiting the ER for dental treatment can be 10 times more expensive than
preventive care. Many visits involve the same patients seeking more care because emergency rooms aren't staffed by dentists. Doctors can offer pain relief, but not
much more, and many patients can't afford follow-up treatment or can't find a dentist. "Emergency rooms are really the canary In the coal mine. If people are
showing up in the ER for dental care, then we've got big holes In the delivery of care," said Shelly Gehshan, director of Pew's child -dentistry campaign. "It's Just like
pouring money down a hole." The Center analyzed Information from 24 states, the Federal Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality and dental care studies. It
found that in 2009, 56 percent of children with Medicaid didn't receive dental care, ER visits for dental care increased by almost 60 percent In South Carolina, and
there were 55,000 dental -related ER visits in Tennessee hospitals. Part of the problem is that few dentists participate In Medicaid programs, The Associated Press
reports. The center Is working with states to develop dental hygienists training programs and train non -dentists to treat cavities and other uncomplicated procedures.
More than 830,000 visits to emergency rooms nationwide in 2009 were for preventable dental problems. Dental disease is the No.1 chronic childhood disease,
sending more children In search of medical treatment than asthma. In a nation obsessed with high-tech medicine, people are not getting preventive care for
something as simple as tooth decay. 6
The following Project Option and Project Components were selected because they directly address Region 12 Community Needs Assessment IDN CN13 (Important
Need): There is a shortage of dental core, and IDA CN3 (Urgent Need): Poor Insurance support or uninsured.
Project Option 1.8: Increase and expand services by Increasing clinics, clinic hours, using satellite mobile clinics with an afRliated fixed -site dental clinic location,
school-based/school-linked health centers or other approaches to Increase oral health services to underserved populations. Project Component: 1.8.6 Expansion of
dental clinic hours
The City of Lubbock will conduct Continuous Quality Improvement (CQI) activities using methods such as rapid cycle Improvement. Activities may include, but are not
limited to, identifying project impacts, identifying "lessons learned," opportunities to scale all or part of the project to a broader patient population and Identifying
key challenges associated with expansion of the project, including special considerations for safety -net populations. Our RHP will encourage participation by all our
partners in a Learning Collaborative that will meet annually to discuss local disparities In care and the ways they have successfully gathered relevant data and
ultimately better served the populations in their projects. in addition to the face-to-face meeting, we will have an open forum on our website that will foster
communication amongst our partners with related projects.
Unique Community Need IDA: CN13 There is a shortage of dental services and CN3 Poor insurance support or uninsured.
Milestones & Metria: The milestones and metrics (1.8.6 — P-4, 4.1; P-10,10.1; and 1-14,14.1) selected for this project directly address CNA13&3 outlined In the
Region 12 Community Needs Assessment.
Related Category 3 Outcome Measure: OD -7 Oral Health; IT -7.7 Urgent Dental Care Needs in Older Adults: Proportion of older adults aged 65 and older with urgent
dental care needs (standalone measure)
Reason/RaUanale for Selection: According to the Region 12 Community Needs Assessment, there is a shortage of dental services and a high prevalence of people
with poor insurance support or who are uninsured. According to the TDA, services for older Texans Is a priority.
Explanation of how focusing on the outcomes will help Improve the health of low -Income populations: Establishment of a new dental clinic focusing services upon
people who are under- or uninsured will directly help Improve the health of low-income populations.
Relationship to Other Projects: This project relates to the City of LubbocVs Pass i project (135103304.1.1— expand access/hours in dental clinic) In that it allows the
new clinic to be open longer hours than possible with only Pass 1 funding. These projects are all related in that they are aimed to Increasing access to needed health
care in the most appropriate setting.
Relationship to Other Performing Providers' Projects In RHP & Plan for Learning Collaborative: This project relates to StarCare's Pass 1 and Pass 2 projects
(084897001.1.1 and 084897001.1.2) - to open a Psychiatric Emergency Service Center and adolescent crisis respite unit — in that this clinic will be housed within the
same facility. Our RHP will encourage participation by all our partners In a "leaming collaborative" that will meet annually to discuss local disparities in care and the
ways they have successfully gathered relevant data and ultimately better served the populations in their projects. In addition to the face-to-face meeting, we will
have an open forum on our website that will foster communication amongst our partners with related projects.
Proleet Valuation!
Criteria
Narrative
Score
This project is designed to achieve, to the greatest extent possible, the Texas Healthcare Transformation and Quality Improvement
Achieves
(1115 Waiver) goals of 1. Improved patient care experience; 2. Improved health; and 3. Reduced cost of healthcare, without
Waiver Goals
compromised quality. In order to achieve alignment with this triple aim, the primary goal of this project is to ensure people receive
Scale:
coordinated, timely and site -appropriate healthcare services. The City of Lubbock hopes to address the healthcare disparity of unequal
5
1 to 5
access for people with low-income. This project will transform healthcare delivery from a disease -focused model of episodic care to a
5 Greatest
patient centered, coordinated delivery model that improves patient satisfaction and health outcomes, reduces un- necessary or
duplicative services and builds on the accomplishments of our existing healthcare system.
Commissioned by the Regional Healthcare Partnership (RHP), the West Texas Area Health Education Center conducted an assessment
Addresses
of the healthcare -related needs in Region 12. The goals of Region 12 are to address as many Identified community needs as possible,
Community
Need(s)
focusing on those identified as "critical" and "urgent," including Increased access to care, increased prevention and early detection
activities and quality/performance Improvement. The following Project Option and Project Components were selected because they
S
Scale:
directly address Region 12 Community Needs Assessment IDN CN13 (important Need): There is o shortage of dental care; and IDN CN3
1 to 5
(Urgent Need): Poor insurance support or uninsured. The lack of available appointments for people without money or insurance,
5 Greatest
results in the need to use emergency rooms for initial contact.
6 httn::i'www.ocwstates.orgluDloadcdl--ilesiP('S Assets/2012!A%2OCostiv' lo2ODental". 2ODestination(i ).pdf
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 12 of 26
135103304.1.2
With Pass 1 funding, the City of Lubbock plans to provide at least 600 office visits in DY4 and to provide at least 750 office visits in DYS,
n/a
Project
serving 350 people per year. Pass 2 funding will allow the City of Lubbock to provide an additional 250 office visits each year in DY4
135303304
scope/Size
and DYS, with capacity to serve 147 more people each year. The City of Lubbock will focus upon special needs patients, pregnant
Scale:
women and/or the elderly hoping for a 10% increase over baseline in DY4 and 15% over baseline In DYS. When considering the impact
4
1 to S
upon each person's care experience, his/her health and the reduced cost upon the community's healthcare delivery system, the scope
5 Greatest
and size of this project will be fairly great. This project will be managed by highly trained staff who specialize in linkage to the right
with urgent dental care needs
core in the right setting.
,
Project
The City of Lubbock's investment in this project will be fairly significant. Staffing will include a Program Director, Dentist(s), Licensed
Milestone 2: [P-10):
Investment
Hygienists, Dentals Technicians, office personnel, etc. (Same administrative staff will be shared with StarCare and Combest in order to
Scale:
obtain economies of scale.) Other investments include physical space, furnishings and equipment, computer hardware/software, etc.
4
1 to 5
As one might Imagine, dental equipment can be very expensive.
existingtrelocate dental care
5 Greatest
with other providers and the RHP to
135103304.1.2
1.8.6
n/a
The expansion of existing
dental clinics, the
establishment of additional
dental clinics or the expansion
of dental clinic hours.
City of Lubbock Health Department
135303304
Urgent Dental Care Need In
Related Category 3 Outcome Measure(s):
135103304.3.2
IT -7.7
Older Adults: Proportion of
older adults aged 6S and older
with urgent dental care needs
,
Milestone 2: [P-10):
Milestone 4: (P-4):
Milestone 6: (1-14)
Participate in face-to-face teaming (i.e.
Establish additional/expand
Increase number of special
meetings or seminars) at least twice per year
existingtrelocate dental care
population members that
with other providers and the RHP to
clinics or space.
access dental services
promote collaborative learning around
shared or similar projects. At each fate -to-
Metric(s): (P-4.11
Metric(s): (1-14.1)
Milestone 1: (P-101:
face meeting, ail providers shall identify and
Number of additional clinics,
15% increase from baseline in
Participate In face-to-face learning (i.e.
agree upon several Improvement (simple
"raise
expanded space, or existing
the number of children, special
meetings or seminars) at least twice per
Initiatives that all providers can do to
available space used to capacity.
needs patients, pregnant
year with other providers and the RHP to
the floor" for performance.) Each
women and/or the elderly
promote collaborative learning around
participating provider should publicly
Baseline/Goal: Add 1 new clinic
accessing dental services.
shared or similar projects. At each face -to-
commit to Implementing these
face meeting, all providers shall identify and
Improvements.
Data source: Tax IDII
Baseline/Gos1:10%Increase
agree upon several Improvement (simple
Metric($): (P-10.1]
Milestone 4 Estimated Incentive
over baseline In the number of
Initiatives that all providers can do to "raise
Participate in semi-annual face-to-face
Payment: $106,001
children, special needs
the floor" for performance.) Each
meetings or seminars organized by the RHP.
patients, pregnant women
participating provider should publicly
and/or the elderly accessing
commit to implementing these
Base0ne/Goal: Participate in face-to-face
Milestone S. (P-31
dental services.
Improvements.
meetings
Increase Interdisciplinary (IDT)
Metrigs): (P-10.1)
training and education for dental
Data source: Claims,
Participate in semi-annual face-to-face
Data source: Documentation of semi-annual
and other health care providers
encounter and clinical record
meetings or seminars organized by the RHP.
meetings, including meeting agendas, slides
to promote an ID Team approach
data
from presentations, and/or meeting notes.
to addressing oral health.
Baseltne/Goal: Participate in face-to-face
Milestone 2 Estimated Incentive Payment:
Metrlc(s): (P3.1)
Milestone 6 Estimated
meetings
$156,186
City of Lubbock will hold
Incentive Payment: $147,698
Data Source: Documentation of semi-
quarterly (4/year) grand rounds,
annual meetings, including meeting
Milestone 3: [P-31
In-service trainings and
agendas, slides from presentations, and/or
Increase Interdisciplinary (IDT) training and
continuing education that focus
Milestone 7: [P-31
education for dental and other health care
on oral health issues and
Increase Interdisciplinary (IDT)
meeting notes.
providers to promote an ID Team approach
Implications as related to chronic
training and education for
Milestone 1 Estimated Incentive Payment:
to addressing oral health.
diseases, such as diabetes and
dental and other health care
$297,150
cardiovascular disease and
providers to promote an ID
Metric(s): (P3.1]
pregnancy.
Team approach to addressing
City of Lubbock will hold quarterly (4/year)
oral health.
grand rounds, in-service trainings and
continuing education that focus on oral
Goal: City of Lubbock will hold
Metric(s): [P3.11
health issues and implications as related to
quarterly (4/year) grand rounds,
City of Lubbock will hold
chronic diseases, such as diabetes and
in-service trainings and
quarterly (4/year) grand
cardiovascular disease and pregnancy.
continuing education that focus
rounds, In-service trainings and
on oral health issues and
continuing education that
Goal: City of Lubbock will hold quarterly
Implications as related to chronic
1 focus on oral health Issues and
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 13 of 26
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 14 of 26
(4/year) grand rounds, in-service trainings
diseases, such as diabetes and
Implications as related to
and continuing education that focus on oral
cardiovascular disease and
chronic diseases, such as
health issues and implications as related to
pregnancy.
diabetes and cardiovascular
chronic diseases, such as diabetes and
disease and pregnancy.
cardiovascular disease and pregnancy.
Data Source: Attendance rosters,
Goal: City of Lubbock will hold
Data Source: Attendance rosters, power
power point presentations, sign
quarterly (4/year) grand
point presentations, sign in sheets, etc.
in sheets, etc.
rounds, in-service trainings and
continuing education that
Milestone 3 Estimated Incentive Payment:
focus on oral health Issues and
$156,185
Milestone 5 Estimated Incentive
Implications as related to
Payment: $106,000
chronic diseases, such as
diabetes and cardiovascular
disease and pregnancy.
Milestone 6: 11-141
Increase number of special
Data Source: Attendance
population members that access
rosters, power point
dental services
presentations, sign in sheets,
etc.
Metric(s): (1-14.1)
10% Increase over baseline In the
number of children, special
Milestone 7 Estimated
needs patients, pregnant women
Incentive Payment: $147,698
and/or the elderly accessing
dental services.
Goal: 10% Increase over baseline
In the number of children, special
needs patients, pregnant women
and/or the elderly accessing
dental services.
Data Source: Claims, encounter
and clinical record data
Milestone 6 Estimated Incentive
Payment: $106,000
DY 2 Estimated Milestone Bundle Amount:
DY 3 Estimated Milestone Bundle Amount:
DY4 Estimated Milestone Bundle
DY5 Estimated Milestone
$297,150
$312,371
Amount: $318,001
Bundle Amount: $295,396
TOTAL ESTIMATED INCENTIVE PAYMENTS FOR 4 -YEAR PERIOD (add milestone bundle amounts over Years 2-5): $1,222,918
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 14 of 26
our nartners with related oroleets. Prolect Valuation:
Criteria
Narrative
Score
Achieves
This project Is designed to achieve, to the greatest extent possible, the Texas Healthcare Transformation and Quality Improvement
Walver Goals
(1115 Waiver) goals of 1. Improved patient care experience; 2. Improved health; and 3. Reduced cost of healthcare, without
Scale:
compromised quality. In order to achieve alignment with this triple aim, the primary goal of this project is to ensure people receive
I to 5
coordinated, timely and site -appropriate healthcare services. The City of Lubbock hopes to address the healthcare disparity of unequal
s
5 Greatest
access for people with low-income. This project will transform healthcare delivery from a disease -focused model of episodic care to a
patient centered, coordinated delivery model that Improves patient satisfaction and health outcomes, reduces unnecessary or
duplicative services and builds on the accomplishments of our existing healthcare system.
Addresses
Commissioned by the Regional Healthcare Partnership (RHP), the West Texas Area Health Education Center conducted an assessment
Community
of the healthcare -related needs In Region 12. The goals of Region 12 are to address as many Identified community needs as possible,
Need(s)
focusing on those identified as "critical" and 'urgent,' Including Increased access to care, Increased prevention and early detection
activities and quality/performance improvement. The following Project Option and Project Components were selected because they
5
Scale:
directly address Region 12 Community Needs Assessment IDN CN13 (Important Need): There is a shortage of dental care; and IDN CN3
1 to 5
(Urgent Need): Poor insurance support or uninsured. The lack of available appointments for people without money or insurance,
5 Greatest
results in the need to use emergency rooms for Initial contact.
Project
The City of Lubbock hopes to provide at least 600 office visits during DY4 and to provide at least 750 office visits in DYS. Conceivably,
Scope/Size
over 350 people per year could be impacted by this project. The City of Lubbock will focus upon special needs patients, pregnant
women and/or the elderly hoping for a 10% Increase over baseline in DY4 and 15% over baseline In DYS. When considering the Impact
4
Scale:
upon each person's care experience, his/her health and the reduced cost upon the community's healthcare delivery system, the scope
1 to S
and size of this project will be fairly great. This project will be managed by highly trained staff who specialize in linkage to the right
5 Greatest
care in the right setting,
Project
The City of Lubbock's Investment in this project will be fairly significant. Staffing will Include a Program Director, Dentist(s), Licensed
Investment
Hygienists, Dentals Technicians, office personnel, etc. (Some administrative staff will be shared with StarCare and Combest in order to
4
Scale:
obtain economles of scale.) Other Investments Include physical space, furnishings and equipment, computer hardware/software, etc.
1 to 5
As one might Imagine, dental equipment can be very expensive.
5 Greatest
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 25 of 26
135103304.1.1
1.8.6
n/a
The expansion of existing
dental clinics, the
establishment of additional
dental clinics or the expansion
of dental Clinic he...
City of Lubbock Health Department
135103304
Urgent Dente) Gre Neetl In
Related Category 3 Outcome Measurels):
135103304.3.1
IT-2.2
of
sugaradltss:ged65 and
older adult aged 65 and
with urgent dental care ..ad,
Milestone 3: [P10 :
Milestone 4: Is 41.
Milestone 6 T1-141
Participate In face to lace learning I.e.
Establish addltlemal/expand
Increase number f special
meetings or seminars) at least twice peryear
existing/relocate dental care
population members that
with other providers and the RHP to
Oltdm or space.
access dental services
promote Collaborative learning around
shared or similar projects. At each face-to-
Mei [P-4.11
Metricsh [1-14.1]
face meetln& all providers shall Identify and
Number of addition[
15% Increase from baseline In
agree upon several Improvement (simple
expanded space, or existing
the number of children. special
Initiatives that all providers can do to "raise
available space used to capacity.
needs patients, pregnant
the Roof for performance.) Each
women and/or the elderly
participating provider should publicly
Baseline/Goal: Add 1 new clinic
accessing dental services.
commit to Implementing these
Improvements.
Dale Source: Tax lop
Milestone 1:(p-101:
Bamllne/Goala0%Increase
Participate In face-todace learning (i.e.
Metric($):[P-10.11
Milestone Estimated Incentive
over baseline In the number of
meetings or seminars) at least twice per
Participate In semi-annual face-to-face
Payment: $7 0,530
children, special needs
year with other providers and the RH P to
meetings or seminars organized by the KH P.
Milestone 5:(P-31
patients, pregnant women
promote collaborative learning around
I unease Indbudisupllnary(I DT)
and/or he elderly accessing
shared or similar projects. At each faceao,
Baseline/Goal: Partldpate In face-to-face
training and educaflon for dental
dental services.
face meeting, all providers shall identify and
meetings
and other health Care providers
agree upon several improvement (simple
to promote an lit Team approach
Date Source: Claims,
initiatives that all providers con do to"ralze
Data Source: Documentation of semi-annual
to addressing oral health.
encounter and Clinical record
the floor" for performance.) Each
meetings, Including meeting agerl slides
data
particlpating provider should publicly
from presentations, and/or meeting notes.
sell IP3.11
commit to Implementing these
City of Lubbock will hold
improvement.
Milestone 2 Estimated Incentive Payment:
quarterly(4/year] grand rounds,
Milestone 6 Estimated
$1,066,396
in-service trainings and
Incentive Payment
Mei (P 10.11
continuing education that focus
$1,102,218
Pamclpate in semi annual face-to-face
Milestone 3:(P-3)
on oral health Issues and
MBeslone T. (P-31
meetings or seminarscIrganlzed by the RHP.
Increase lnterdlsdpllnary(for) training and
implications as related to Chronic
Increase lnterdlscipllnary(for)
education for Dental and other health Care
diseases, such as diabetes and
tralNng and education for
providers to promote an to Team approach
cardiovesmlar disease and
dental and other health care
Basellne/Goal: Participate In face-to-face
to addressing oral health.
pragmatics.
providers to promote an to
meetings
Team approach to addressing
Metrit[s1:[P3.11
Goal: City of Lubbock will hold
oral health.
Data source: Documentation of sem4
City of Lubbock will hold quarterly (4/year)
quarterly(4/year) Wand rounds,
annual meeting; including meeting
grand rounds, in- service trainings and
imsetvlm trainings and
MCMHs): IP3.11
agendas, slides from presentations, and/or
Continuing education that focus on oral
continuing education that focus
City of Lubbock will held
meeting notes.
health Issues and irnmil lops as related to
on oral health Issues and
quarterly(4/yead grand
Chronic diseases, such as diabetes and
Implications as rNated to chronic
coupon, in-service tralnings and
Milestone l Estimated Incentive Payment:
Cardiovascular disease and pregnai
diseases, such as diabetes and
continuing education that
$1,942,214
cardiovascular d"uesse and
focus on oral health issues and
Goal: City of Lubbock will hold quarterly
pregnancy.
implications as related to
(4/yei grand rounds, in-service trainings
chronic diseases, such as
and Continuing education that focus on oral
Data Source: Attendance rosters,
diabetes and cardlovesmlar
health issues and implications as related to
power point presentations, sign
disease and pregrucv.
chronic diseases, such as diabetes and
in sheets, etc.
cardiovascular disease and pregnancy.
Goal: City of Lubbock will hold
Milestone S Estimated Incentive
quarterly i4/yearl grand
Data Scum: Attendance posters, power
Payment: $260,530
pounds, In-service trainings and
paint presentations, sign In sheets, etc.
continuing education that
Milectone6: [I-141
focus on oral health issues and
Milestone 3 Estimated Incentive Payment:
Increase number of special
implications as related to
$1,066,395
papulation members that access
chronic d lseases, such as
dental services
diabetes and cardiovascular
disease and pregnancy.
Metral [1-14.11
10%increase mearbaselinelnthe
Dat Sperm: Attendance
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 16 of 26
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 17 of 26
number of children, special
rosters, power point
needs patients, pregnant women
presentations, sign in sheets,
and/or the elderly accessing
etc.
dental services.
Goal: 10% Increase over baseline
Milestone 7 Estimated
In the number of children, special
Incentive Payment:
needs patients, pregnant women
$1,102,217
and/or the elderly accessing
dental services.
Data Source: Claims, encounter
and clinical record data
Milestone 6 Estimated Incentive
Payment: $760,530
DY 2 Estimated Milestone Bundle Amount:
DY 3 Estimated Milestone Bundle Amount:
DY4 Estimated Milestone Bundle
DYS Estimated Milestone
$1,942,214
$2,132,791
Amount: $2,281,590
Bundle Amount: $2,204,435
TOTAL ESTIMATED INCENTIVE PAYMENTS FOR 4 -YEAR PERIOD (add milestone bundle amounts over Years 2-5): $8,561,029
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 17 of 26
Project Option: 1.8.6 - The expansion of existing dental clinics, the establishment of additional dental cllnics or the expansion of dental clinic hours. Performing
Provider: City of Lubbock Health Department/135103304
Unique Project ID:135103304.1.2 — "PASS r
PROVIDER: The City of Lubbock, Texas Is currently home to over 229,000 residents. The City of Lubbock Health Department's mission is to protect the health, safety
and welfare of citizens through: 1. Preventing epidemics and the spread of disease; 2. Educating and empowering people to adopt health and responsible
behaviors; 3. Promoting the quality and accessibility of health services; and 4. Developing new insights and Innovative solutions to health problems.
INTERVENTIONSThe City of Lubbock Health Department will expand dental services, through the establishment of a new dental clinic.
NEED FOR THE PROJECT: The City of Lubbock selected this project because it directly addresses Region 12 Community Needs Assessment ID# CN13 (Important
Need): There is a shortage of dental care; and ID# CN3 (Urgent Need): Poor insurance support or uninsured. The City of Lubbock does not currently operate a dental
clinic; therefore, this will be a new endeavor.
TARGET POPULATION: The target population for this project Includes people who don't historically have access to or avail themselves of dental care: people with
mental illness, substance abuse Issues, intellectual disabilities, people who are homeless, people struggling with the challenges of aging, veterans, people living in
poverty, etc. Estimates are that 95% of the people served in this new clinic will be Medicaid funded or indigent.
CATEGORY 1 EXPECTED PATIENT BENEFITS: During DY3 the City of Lubbock will hire and train staff, develop all operational protocols and clinical guidelines and
develop a baseline from which to calculate system Improvements. With Pass 1 funding, the City of Lubbock plans to provide at least 600 office visits In DY4 and to
provide at least 750 office visits in DYS, serving 350 people per year. Pass 2 funding will allow the City of Lubbock to provide an additional 250 office visits each year
in DY4 and DYS, with capacity to serve 147 more people each year. The City of Lubbock will focus upon special needs patients, pregnant women and/or the elderly
hoping for a 10% increase over baseline in DY4 and 15% over baseline in DYS.
CATEGORY 3 OUTCOMES: (IT — 7.7) The goal of this project is to decrease of older adults 65 years or olderwlth urgent dental care needsby 10% from baseline in DY4
and 15% from baseline In DYS.
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 18 of 26
Project Option: 1.8.6 - The expansion of existing dental clinics, the establishment of additional dental clinics or the expansion of dental clinic hours.
Performing Provider. City of Lubbock Health Department/135103304
Unique Project ID: 135103304.1.2 - "PASS 2"
Project Description: During Pass 2, the City of Lubbock will expand Its Pass 1 project (which was to establish a new dental clinic) in two 12) ways: 1. Serve more
people than possible with Pass 1 funding alone and 2. Expand dental clinic hours from those anticipated with Pass 1 funding.
Dental health is a key component of overall health. Oral disease can lead to poor nutrition; serious systemic illnesses and conditions such as poor birth outcomes,
diabetes and cardiovascular disease; and a diminished quality of life and life expectancy. Inadequate access to oral health services compounds other health issues.
can result in untreated dental disease that not only affects the mouth, but can also have physical, mental, economic and social consequences. Fortunately, many of
the adverse effects associated with poor oral health can be prevented with quality regular dental care, both at home and professionally. Increasing, expanding and
enhancing oral health services will improve health outcomes.
The Texas Dental Association (TDA) looked carefully at the economic, medical and social consequences of untreated oral disease in Texas. It reviewed the current
systems of oral health care delivery, assessed payment structures, and studied the oral health status of Texans in general and analyzed the oral health disparities that
exist in the state. Then TDA made specific and practical policy recommendations to expand access to oral health care In Texas, Including: Identifying a "dental home"
for every citizen, creating new programs to encourage general dentists and specialists to practice in underserved areas and to treat underserved populations,
developing a comprehensive oral health public awareness and education campaign; and expanding access to oral health services for older citizens.
This project (in combination with the City of Lubbock's Pass 1 project) focuses upon all of these state priorities by establishing a new dental clinic, targeting people
who don't historically have access to or avail themselves of dental care: people with mental Illness, substance abuse Issues, Intellectual disabilities, people who are
homeless, people struggling with the challenges of aging, veterans, people living in poverty, etc. The City of Lubbock Health Department (City of Lubbock) does not
have adequate resources to meet the demand for dental services in Lubbock, especially for populations with special needs. This project sets forth collaboration with
the Local Mental Health Authority (StarCare Specialty Health System "StarCare") and a Federally Qualified Health Center (the Texas Tech School of Nursing's Federally
Qualified Health Center, The Larry Combest Center for Health and Wellness "Combest") to obtain synergy, economies of scale and to Increase access for preventative
dental visits Impacting the severity of going to the dentist as a last resort. This project will help divert patients from more expensive, less effective treatment of
extreme dental procedures.
The City of Lubbock plans to partner with StarCare and Combest to engage a Lubbock Oral Health Project Coordinator to conduct a city-wide needs assessment
related to citizens of all ages, to perform a gap analysis and to develop a dental coalition of all providers of dental services to people with low income. In addition, the
coalition will develop a Lubbock Oral Health Plan and begin implementation of the Lubbock Oral Health Program. Next, the City of Lubbock, StarCare and Combest
will partner to open a new dental clinic, to include the development of policies and procedures and hiring and training staff. The initial plan is to co -locate with a new
integrated physical and behavioral health clinic in StarCare's Psychiatric Emergency Service Center in order to Improve access to marginalized populations. With Pass
1 funding, the City of Lubbock plans to provide at least 600 office visits in DY4 and to provide at least 750 office visits in DYS, serving 350 people per year. Pass 2
funding will allow the City of Lubbock to provide an additional 250 office visits each year in DY4 and DYS, with capacity to serve 147 more people each year. The City
of Lubbock will focus upon special needs patients, pregnant women and/or the elderly hoping for a 10% increase over baseline In DY4 and 15% over baseline in DYS.
Goal of Project: The primary goals of this project are to: close gaps/disparities in access to dental care services and to enhance the quality of dental care provided.
Challenges: Challenges associated with the successful implementation of this project are: lack of qualified dental providers, patient transportation and
low oral health literacy. The City of Lubbock will work with its project partners to develop and implement a comprehensive provider recruitment effort and public
information campaign. The dental clinic will likely provide bus passes to patients to help address Issues related to transportation.
S -Year Expected Outcome for Performing Provider and Patients: Performing Provider Perspective — improved healthcare infrastructure that better serves the
Medicaid -funded and uninsured residents of our counties; coordinated care delivery system; improved efficiency and cost growth containment.
• Patient Perspective— high quality, patient -centered care; improved access to coordinated healthcare; improved health outcomes.
Relationship to Regional Goals: Commissioned by the Regional Healthcare Partnership (RHP), the West Texas Area Health Education Center conducted an
assessment of the healthcare -related needs In Region 12. The resulting document ranked the needs In tiers, according to the availability of evidence documenting
each need. Tier one included the two (2) most pressing needs In RHP 12:1) a severe lack of primary care access including provider shortages, financial barriers, wait
times, and length of time to get an appointment; and 2) a lack of mental health services including lack of available appointments, insurance coverage, and emergency
room usage for mental health Issues. Tier two Identified other priority issues as: 1) uninsured and underinsured; 2) high incidence of obesity, diabetes, and heart
disease; 3) need for specialty care; and 4) need for cancer screenings; and 5) insufficient maternal and prenatal care. The goals of Region 12 are to address as many
identified community needs as possible, focusing on those identified as "critical" and "urgent," including Increased access to care, Increased prevention and early
detection activities and quality/performance improvement.
This project is directly related to the Region 12 goals of increased access to care and increased prevention and early detection activities. This project will transform
healthcare delivery from a disease -focused model of episodic care to a patient centered, coordinated delivery model that Improves patient satisfaction and health
outcomes, reduces unnecessary or duplicative services and builds on the accomplishments of our existing healthcare system.
Starting Point/Baseline: The City of Lubbock does not currently operate a dental clinic; therefore, the starting point/baseline for the number of people to be assisted
is zero.
Reason/Rationale for Selecting Measure: Poor oral health affects more than just the mouth. It can seriously compromise a person's general health, quality of life and
life expectancy. Oral diseases can and do lead to systemic problems — damaging other parts of the body and resulting in the need for expensive emergency
department visits, hospital stays and medications. The consequences of poor oral health, however, go far beyond damaging medical effects. Oral disease con also
wreak economic havoc — keeping children out of school and adults home from work — not to mention lower productivity of workers In pain. Untreated oral diseases
can also drive up healthcare costs in general. The good news Is that with proper oral healthcare, both at home and in professional settings, many of the negative
consequences associated with poor oral health can be prevented.7
lttn://WWW,bUildingbetterorallicallb.orginediaCj'DA full renort.pdf
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 19 of 26
The number of emergency -room visits for patients seeking dental treatment has Increased, mostly because of problems that could have been prevented with regular
dental visits, according to the Pew Center on the States. Most cases are In rural areas, which have a shortage of dentists. Nationwide, the number of ER dental visits
increased 16 percent from 2006 to 2009, and the center suggests the trend is continuing. Visiting the ER for dental treatment can be 10 times more expensive than
preventive care. Many visits involve the same patients seeking more care because emergency rooms aren't staffed by dentists. Doctors can offer pain relief, but not
much more, and many patients can't afford follow-up treatment or can't find a dentist. "Emergency rooms are really the canary in the coal mine. if people are
showing up in the ER for dental care, then we've got big holes In the delivery of care,' said Shelly Gehshan, director of Pew's child -dentistry campaign. "It's Just like
pouring money down a hole." The Center analyzed Information from 24 states, the Federal Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality and dental care studies. It
found that in 2009, 56 percent of children with Medicaid didn't receive dental pre, ER visits for dental care Increased by almost 60 percent in South Carolina, and
there were 55,000 dental -related ER visits in Tennessee hospitals. Part of the problem Is that few dentists participate In Medicaid programs, The Associated Press
reports. The center Is working with states to develop dental hygienists training programs and train non -dentists to treat cavities and other uncomplicated procedures.
More than 830,000 visits to emergency rooms nationwide in 2009 were for preventable dental problems. Dental disease Is the No. l chronic childhood disease,
sending more children in search of medical treatment than asthma. In a nation obsessed with high-tech medicine, people are not getting preventive care for
something as simple as tooth decay. °
The following Project Option and Project Components were selected because they directly address Region 12 Community Needs Assessment ID# CN13 (Important
Need): There is a shortage of dental care; and ID# CN3 (Urgent Need): Poor Insurance support or uninsured.
Project Option 1.8: Increase and expand services by increasing clinics, clinic hours, using satellite mobile clinics with an affiliated fixed -site dental clinic location,
school-based/school-linked health centers or other approaches to increase oral health services to underserved populations. Project Component: 1.8.6 Expansion of
dental clinic hours
The City of Lubbock will conduct Continuous Quality Improvement (CQI) activities using methods such as rapid cycle improvement. Activities may Include, but are not
limited to, identifying project impacts, Identifying "lessons learned," opportunities to scale all or part of the project to a broader patient population and Identifying
key challenges associated with expansion of the project, including special considerations for safety -net populations. Our RHP will encourage participation by all our
partners in a Learning Collaborative that will meet annually to discuss local disparities In care and the ways they have successfully gathered relevant data and
ultimately better served the populations In their projects. In addition to the face-to-face meeting, we will have an open forum on our website that will foster
communication amongst our partners with related projects.
Unique Community Need IDN: CN13 There is a shortage of dental services and CN3 Poor insurance support or uninsured.
Milestones & Metria: The milestones and metria (1.8.6 — P-4, 4.1; P-10,10.1; and 1-14, 14.1) selected for this project directly address CN#13&3 outlined in the
Region 12 Community Needs Assessment.
Related Category 3 Outcome Measure: OD -7 Oral Health; IT -7.7 Urgent Dental Care Needs In Older Adults: Proportion of older adults aged 65 and older with urgent
dental care needs (standalone measure)
Reason/Rationale for Selection: According to the Region 12 Community Needs Assessment, there is a shortage of dental services and a high prevalence of people
with poor insurance support or who are uninsured. According to the TDA, services for older Texans is a priority.
Explanation of how focusing on the outcomes will help improve the health of low-income populations: Establishment of a new dental clinic focusing services upon
people who are under- or uninsured will directly help Improve the health of low-income populations.
Relationship to Other Projects: This project relates to the City of Lubbock's Pau 1 project (135103304.1.1— expand access/hours In dental clinic) in that it allows the
new clinic to be open longer hours than possible with only Pass 1 funding. These projects are all related in that they are aimed to Increasing access to needed health
care in the most appropriate setting.
Relationship to Other Performing Providers' Projects In RHP & Plan for learning collaborative: This project relates to StarCare's Pass land Pass 2 projects
(084897001.1.1 and 084897001.1.2) - to open a Psychiatric Emergency Service Center and adolescent crisis respite unit — In that this clinic will be housed within the
same facility. Our RHP will encourage participation by all our partners in a'learning collaborative that will meet annually to discuss local disparities in care and the
ways they have successfully gathered relevant data and ultimately better served the populations in their projects. In addition to the face-to-face meeting, we will
have an open forum on our website that will foster communication amongst our partners with related projects.
Prolect Valuation:
criteria
Narrative
score
This project is designed to achieve, to the greatest extent possible, the Texas Healthcare Transformation and Quality Improvement
Achieves
(1115 Waiver) goals of 1. Improved patient care experience; 2. Improved health; and 3. Reduced cost of healthcare, without
Waiver Goals
compromised quality. In order to achieve alignment with this triple aim, the primary goal of this project is to ensure people receive
Scale:
coordinated, timely and site -appropriate healthcare services. The City of Lubbock hopes to address the healthcare disparity of unequal
S
1 to 5
access for people with low-income. This project will transform healthcare delivery from a disease -focused model of episodic care to a
5 Greatest
patient centered, coordinated delivery model that improves patient satisfaction and health outcomes, reduces un- necessary or
duplicative services and builds on the accomplishments of our existing healthcare system.
Addresses
Commissioned by the Regional Healthcare Partnership (RHP), the West Texas Area Health Education Center conducted an assessment
of the healthcare -related needs in Region 12. The goals of Region 12 are to address as many Identified community needs as possible,
Community
Need(s)
focusing on those Identified as "critical" and "urgent,' including Increased access to care, Increased prevention and early detection
Scale:
activities and quality/performance improvement. The following Project Option and Project Components were selected because they
S
directly address Region 12 Community Needs Assessment IDN CN13 (Important Need): There Is a shortage of dental core; and ID# CN3
I to 5
(Urgent Need): Poor Insurance support or uninsured. The lack of available appointments for people without money or insurance,
5 Greatest
results in the need to use emergency rooms for initial contact.
a http: ,"www.pewstates.oreluploadedFilesiPCS Assctsi20l2/A"o2OCostly°b2Ol)ental°o2ODeslinistian(1),I)df
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 20 of 26
13 510 3 3 0 4.1.2
With Pass 1 funding the City of Lubbock plans to provide at least 600 office vlslts In DY4 and to provide at least 750 office visits In DY5,
Ma
Project
serving 350 people per year. Pass 2 funding will allow the City of Lubbock to provide an additional 250 office vlslts each year In DY4
135103304
Snipe/Size
and DY5, with capacity to serve 147 more People each year. The City of Lubbock will focus upon special needs patients, pregnant
Scale:
women and/or the elderly hoping for a l0% Increase over baseline In DY4 and 15% over baseline In OYS. When considering the Impact
4
l toy
upon each person's care experience, his/her health and the reduced cost upon thecommunity's healthcare delivery system, the scope
S Greatest
and site of this project will be fairly great. This project will be managed by highly trained staff who specialize in linkage to the right
older adults aged 65 and older
core in the right setting.
Project
The City of Lubbock's investment In this project will be fairly significant. Staffing will Include a Program Director, Dentist($), Licensed
a
Investment
Hygienists, Denials Technicians, office personnel, etc. (Some administrative staff will be shared with Startare and Compost in order to
Scale:
obtain economies of scale.] Other investments Include physlCal space. furnishings and equipmenC Computer hardware/software, etc
4
l to
As one might Imagine, dental equipment can be ve ry expensive.
Establishadditianebc.penp
5 Greatest
meetings or seminars) at least tela per year
13 510 3 3 0 4.1.2
1.8.6
Ma
The expanslon of existing
dental clinics, the
establishment of additional
dental dinles or the expansion
of dental clinic boon.
C of Lubbock Health De a IT t
135103304
Urgent Dental Ore Need In
Related Category 3Out come Meaure(sl:
1351033043.2
IT 7,7
Older Adults: Proportion of
older adults aged 65 and older
with ur ent dental care needs
a
Milestone 2: P 10I:
Milestone 4: IR 4'
Mllestene 6: lh14j
Participate In faceioface learning (i.e.
Establishadditianebc.penp
Increase number of spacial
meetings or seminars) at least tela per year
existing/relocate dental cafe
population members that
with other Provides and the RHP to
cllnlu or space.
access dental services
promote collaborative learning around
Shared or similar proletts. At each face -to-
Metai IP4.1]
Metric(s): 1614.11
Milestone l:(P4o1:
face meeMg all providers shall identify and
Number of additional clinics,
15% Increase from baseline In
Paract,ate In face -to face learning (i.e.
agree upon several improvement(simple
expanded space, or existing
the number of children, special
meetings orseminars)at leasttwlce per
initiatives that all providers can do to 'raise
available space used to capacity.
needs patients, pregnant
the Oao('for performance.) Each
women antl/onhe elderly
pcovl
year with other ders and the RHP t0
participating provider should publicly
Basellne/Gwl: Add l new clinic
accessing dental services.
promos collaborative
At
ach
mit to implementing these
eng
projects. facround
fcetrinihared or projects. eaNntify n
face meeting all providers SM1all itlentify and
ng, all shall
Improvements.
Data Source: Tax lop
agree upon sawal Improvement (simple
Baseline/Ga L• ase
initiatives that all providers can do to "false
4611ma1ldincentive
overren,spcia baseline In ihenumber of
the number
the fiooc for performance.) Each
ParticMetHt(stein semi
Payment•. 5106,001
PaymMilesent:
children, eds
partitlpaing provider should publicly
meetings
meetings or seminars organized by the RHP.
organize by
pregame women
patients. pregnant women
commit to Implementing these
and/or she elderly accessing
Improvements.
asee/Goal: Participate In face to lace
Blin
Milestone 5: is 31
dental services.
meati.,
Inc
Increase lnnertllscipllnaryllDT)
Mehk(sl:(P-30.11
training and Pat ucation for dental
Data Source: Claims,
Participate in semFannual faceterface
Data Source: Documentation of semi-annual
and other health care providers
encounter and clinical record
meetings or seminars organized by the RNP.
m
meetings, including meeting agendas, slides
to promote an to Team approach
data
from presentations, and/or meeting notes.
to addressing oral health.
Basellne/Goal: Participate In taps -to dace
Milestone 2 Estimated Incentive Payment
Metai (P3.11
Milestone 6 Estimated
meetings
$1561
City of Lubbock will hold
lacemiYe Payment: 5147,698
Data Source: Documentation dsemi-
quarterly (4/year) grand Pounds,
annual meetings, Actutling meeting
Milestone 3:(P-31
In-service tralnings and
agendas, slides from mesentatlons, and/or
Increase Interdisciplinary UDT) training and
continuing education that locus
Milestone 7: IP a1
education for dental and other health care
on oral health issues and
Increase Interdisciplinary (IDT)
agendas notes,
provitlen to promote an to Team approach
implications as human to chronic
training and education for
Milestone l Estimated incentive Payment:
to addressing aal health.
diseases, such psa diabetes and
dental and other health cafe
5297,150
ardiovauular disease and
providers to promote an lD
Metds(sk (P3.11
pregnanry.
Team approach to adtlressiPit
City of Lubbock will hold quarterly (4/year)
and health,
Wand rounds, imseMep tainings and
continuing education that focus on oral
Goal: City of Lubbock will hold
metal,): jP3.11
healtfllsmesand implications as related t0
quarterly (4/year) grand rounds,
City of Lubbock will hold
chronic diseases, such as diabetes and
In servlce tralnings and
quarterly (4/inar)gand
cardiovascular disease and pregnanry,
continuing education that focus
rounds, In service tralnings and
on oalM1eallM1 fusses antl
Continuing education that
Goal: Ci of Lubbock will hold quarterly
Inv II<ationsasalaledto chronic
hennson oral healthesues and
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 21 of 26
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 22 of 26
(4/year) grand rounds, In-service trainings
diseases, such as diabetes and
implications as related to
and continuing education that focus on oral
cardiovascular disease and
chronic diseases, such as
health Issues and Implications as related to
pregnancy.
diabetes and cardiovascular
chronic diseases, such as diabetes and
disease and pregnancy.
cardiovascular disease and pregnancy.
Data Source: Attendance rosters,
Goal: City of Lubbock will hold
Data Source: Attendance rosters, power
power point presentations, sign
quarterly (4/year) grand
point presentations, sign in sheets, etc.
in sheets, etc.
rounds, in-service trainings and
continuing education that
Milestone 3 Estimated Incentive Payment:
focus on oral health Issues and
$156,185
Milestone 5 Estimated Incentive
Implications as related to
Payment: $106,000
chronic diseases, such as
diabetes and cardiovascular
disease and pregnancy.
Milestone 6: (1.14]
Increase number of special
Data Source: Attendance
population members that access
rosters, power point
dental services
presentations, sign in sheets,
etc.
Metric(s): (1-14.11
10% Increase over baseline In the
number of children, special
Milestone 7 Estimated
needs patients, pregnant women
Incentive Payment: $147,698
and/or the elderly accessing
dental services.
Goal: 10% increase over baseline
in the number of children, special
needs patients, pregnant women
and/or the elderly accessing
dental services.
Data Source: Claims, encounter
and clinical record data
Milestone 6 Estimated Incentive
Payment: $106,000
DY 2 Estimated Milestone Bundle Amount:
DY 3 Estimated Milestone Bundle Amount:
DY4 Estimated Milestone Bundle
DY5 Estimated Milestone
$297,150
$312,371
Amount: $318,001
Bundle Amount: $295,396
TOTAL ESTIMATED INCENTIVE PAYMENTS FOR 4 -YEAR PERIOD (add milestone bundle amounts over Years 2-5): $1,222,918
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 22 of 26
Outcome Measure Title: IT -7.7 Urgent Dental Care Needs In Older Adults
Performing Provider. City of Lubbock Health Department/135103304
Unique RHP Outcome ID: 135103304.3.3
Outcome Domain: OD -7 Oral Health
Outcome Measure Description:
IT -7.7 - Urgent Dental Care Needs In Older Adults
In order to achieve the goals and desired outcomes of this project, the following Process Milestones and Outcome Improvement Targets were selected:
Process Milestones:
Year DY2:
Year DY3:
Outcome Improvement Targets:
Year DY4:
Year DYS:
Category 3— P-1: Project planning—engage stakeholders, Identify current capacity and needed resources, determine timeliness,
and document Implementation plans.
Data Source: Implementation plan
Category 3 — P-2: Establish baseline rates
Data Source: Performing Provider Utilization Data, Emergency Department Data
IT -7.7: Urgent dental care needs in older adults
Improvement Target: Decrease the number of older adults 65 years or older with urgent dental care needs by
10% from baseline
Data Source: EHR, claims
IT— 7.7: Urgent dental care needs In older adults
Improvement Target: Decrease the number of older adults 65 years or older with urgent dental care needs by
1S% from baseline
Data Source: EHR, claims
Rationale:
The above outcome measure, process milestones and outcome improvement targets were selected because they directly address Region 12 Community
Needs Assessment IDN CN13 (important Need): There is a shortage of dental care, and IDN CN3 (Urgent Need): Poor Insurance support or uninsured. Establishment of
a new dental clinic will allow people access to specialized Interventions, in order to avoid exacerbation of health problems.
Outcome Measure Valuation:
criteria
Narrative
Score
Achieves
This project is designed to achieve, to the greatest extent possible, the Texas Healthcare Transformation and Quality Improvement
(1115 Waiver) goals of 1. Improved patient care experience; 2. Improved health; and 3. Reduced cost of healthcare, without
Waiver Goals
compromised quality. In order to achieve alignment with this triple aim, the primary goal of this project Is to ensure patients receive
Scale-
coordinated, timely and site -appropriate healthcare services. The City of Lubbock hopes to address the healthcare disparity of unequal
5
1 t05
access for people with low-income. This project will transform healthcare delivery from a disease -focused model of episodic pre to a
5 Greatest
patient centered, coordinated delivery model that Improves patient satisfaction and health outcomes, reduces unnecessary or
duplicative services and builds on the accomplishments of our existing healthcare system.
Commissioned by the Regional Healthcare Partnership (RHP), the West Texas Area Health Education Center conducted an assessment
Addresses
of the healthcare -related needs in Region 12. The goals of Region 12 are to address as many Identified community needs as possible,
Community
Need(s)
focusing on those identified as "critical' and "urgent," Including increased access to pre, increased prevention and early detection
Scale:
activities and quality/performance Improvement. The City of Lubbock's new dental clinic directly relates to the Region 12 Community
5
Needs Assessment IDN CN13 (Important Need): There is a shortage of dental care; and IDN CN3 (Urgent Need): Poor Insurance support
1 to 5
or uninsured. Establishment of a new dental clinic will allow people access to specialized interventions, In order to avoid exacerbation
5 Greatest
of health problems.
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 23 of 26
135303304.3.1 3.IT-7.7 Urgent dental care needs in older adults
During DY3 the City of Lubbock will hire and train staff, develop all operational protocols and clinical guidelines and develop a baseline
Related Category Project:
Project
from which to calculate system improvements. The City of Lubbock hopes to provide at least 600 office visits during DY4 and to
To be determined In DY3
Scope/Size
provide at least 750 office visits In DYS. Conceivably, over 350 people per year could be impacted by this project. The City of Lubbock
Scale:
will focus upon special needs patients, pregnant women and/or the elderly hoping for a 10% increase over baseline in DY4 and 15%
4
1 to 5
over baseline in DYS. in DY4, the City of Lubbock hopes to decrease the number of elderly adults with urgent care needs by 10%
Outcome improvement Target 1:
5 Greatest
under baseline and to decrease 15% under baseline in DYS.When considering the impact upon each person's care experience, his/her
Establish baseline rates
IT7.7: Urgent dental care needs in
health and the reduced cost upon the community's healthcare delivery system, the scope and size of this project will be fairly great.
stakeholders, identify current
This project will be managed by highly trained staff who specialize In linkage to the right care in the rihtsettin .
older adults
Project
The City of Lubbock's investment In this project will be fairly significant. Staffing will include a Program Director, Dentist(s), Licensed
Investment
Hygienists, Dentals Technicians, office personnel, etc. (Some administrative staff will be shared with StarCare and Combest in order to
Scale:
obtain economies of scale.) Other investments include physical space, furnishings and equipment, computer hardware/software, etc.
4
1 to 5
As one might imagine, dental equipment can be very expensive.
Decrease the number of older adults
5 Greatest
older with urgent dental care needs by
135303304.3.1 3.IT-7.7 Urgent dental care needs in older adults
City of Lubbock, Health Department 135103304
Related Category Project:
135103304.1.1
Starting Point/Baseline:
To be determined In DY3
Process Milestone 1: P-1
Process Milestone 2: P-2
Outcome improvement Target 1:
Outcome Improvement Target 2:
Project planning —engage
Establish baseline rates
IT7.7: Urgent dental care needs in
177.7: Urgent dental care needs In
stakeholders, identify current
older adults
older adults
capacity and needed resources,
determine timeliness and document
Improvement Target: Decrease the
Improvement Target:
implementation plans.
number of older adults 65 years or
Decrease the number of older adults
older with urgent dental care needs by
65 years or older with urgent dental
10% from baseline
care needs by 15% from baseline
Data Source: Implementation Plan
Data Source: PP Utilization Data,
Data Source: PP Utilization Data,
Data Source: PP Utilization Data,
Clinic Utilization Data
Clinic Utilization Data
Process Milestone 1 Estimated
Clinic Utilization Data
Incentive Payment: $102,222
Estimated Outcome Improvement
Estimated Outcome Improvement
Process Milestone 2 Estimated i
Target 1 Incentive Payment: $253,510
Target 2 Incentive Payment: $551,109
Incentive Payment:
$236,977
DY 2 Estimated Outcome Amount:
DY 3 Estimated Outcome Amount:
DY4 Estimated Outcome Amount:
DY S Estimated Outcome Amount:
$102,222
$236,977
$253,510
$551,109
TOTAL ESTIMATED INCENTM PAYMENTS FOR 4 -YEAR PERIOD: $1,143,817
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 24 of 26
Outcome Measure Title: IT -7.7 Urgent Dental Care Needs In Older Adults
Performing Provider: City of Lubbock Health Department/135103304
Unique RHP Outcome ID: 135203304.3.2 'PASS r
Outcome Domain: OD -7 Oral Health
Outcome Measure Description:
IT -7.7 - Urgent Dental Care Needs in Older Adults
In order to achieve the goals and desired outcomes of this project, the following Process Milestones and Outcome Improvement Targets were selected:
Process Milestones:
Year DY2:
Year DY3:
Outcome Improvement Targets:
Year DY4:
Year DYS:
Category 3— P-1: Project planning— engage stakeholders, identify current capacity and needed resources, determine timeliness,
and document implementation plans.
Data Source: Implementation plan
Category 3 — P-2: Establish baseline rates
Data Source: Performing Provider Utilization Data, Emergency Department Data
IT -7.7: Urgent dental care needs In older adults
Improvement Target: Decrease the number of older adults 65 years or older with urgent dental care needs by
10% from baseline
Data Source: EHR, claims
IT— 7.7: Urgent dental care needs in older adults
Improvement Target: Decrease the number of older adults 65 years or older with urgent dental pre needs by
15% from baseline
Data Source: EHR, claims
Rationale:
The above outcome measure, process milestones and outcome Improvement targets were selected because they directly address Region 12 Community Needs
Assessment IDB CN13 (Important Need): There is a shortage of dental care, and IDB CN3 (Urgent Need): Poor Insurance support or uninsured. Establishment of a new
dental clinic will allow people access to specialized interventions, in order to avoid exacerbation of health problems.
Outcome Measure Valuation:
Criteria
Narrative
Score
Achieves
This project is designed to achieve, to the greatest extent possible, the Texas Healthcare Transformation and Quality Improvement
Waiver Goals
(1115 Waiver) goals of 1. Improved patient care experience; 2. Improved health; and 3. Reduced cost of healthcare, without
Scale:
compromised quality. In order to achieve alignment with this triple aim, the primary goal of this project Is to ensure patients receive
coordinated, timely and site -appropriate healthcare services. The City of Lubbock hopes to address the healthcare disparity of unequal
5
I to 5
access for people with low-income. This project will transform healthcare delivery from a disease -focused model of episodic care to a
5 Greatest
patient centered, coordinated delivery model that Improves patient satisfaction and health outcomes, reduces unnecessary or
duplicative services and builds on the accomplishments of our existing healthcare system.
Addresses
Commissioned by the Regional Healthcare Partnership (RHP), the West Texas Area Health Education Center conducted an assessment
Community
of the healthcare -related needs in Region 12. The goals of Region 12 are to address as many identified community needs as possible,
'critical' 'urgent,"
Need(s)
focusing on those identified as and including increased access to care, Increased prevention and early detection
Scale:
activities and quality/performance improvement. The City of Lubbodes new dental clinic directly relates to the Region 12 Community
5
Needs Assessment IDB CN23 (Important Need): There is o shortage of dental core; and IDB CN3 (Urgent Need): Poor Insurance support
I to 5
or uninsured. Establishment of anew dental clinic will allow people access to specialized interventions, in order to avoid exacerbation
5 Greatest
of health problems.
During DY3 the City of Lubbock will hire and train staff, develop all operational protocols and clinical guidelines and develop a baseline
from which to calculate system Improvements. With Pass 1 funding, the City of Lubbock plans to provide at least 600 office visits in
DY4 and to provide at least 750 office visits in DYS, serving 350 people per year. Pau 2 funding will allow the city of Lubbock to
Project
Scope/Size
provide an additional 250 office visits each year In DY4 and DYS, with capacity to serve 147 more people each year. The City of
Scale:
Lubbock will focus upon special needs patients, pregnant women and/or the elderty hoping for a 10% Increase over baseline in DY4
4
and 15% over baseline in DYS. 10% increase over baseline in DY4 and 15% over baseline In DYS. In DY4, the City of Lubbock hopes to
1 to
decrease the number of elderly adults with urgent care needs by 10% under baseline and to decrease 15% under baseline in
5 Greatest
DYS.When considering the impact upon each person's care experience, his/her health and the reduced cost upon the community's
healthcare delivery system, the scope and size of this project will be fairly great. This project will be managed by highly trained staff
who specialize in linkage to the right core In the right setting,
Project
The City of Lubbock's Investment in this project will be fairly significant. Staffing will Include a Program Director, Dentist(s), Licensed
Investment
Hygienists, Dentals Technicians, office personnel, etc. (Some administrative staff will be shared with StarCare and Combest In order to
4
Scale:
obtain economies of scale.) Other investments include physical space, furnishings and equipment, computer hardware/software, etc.
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 25 of 26
I to 5I As one might Imagine, dental equipment can be very expensive.
5 Greatest
135103304.3.2 3.IT-7.7 Urgent dental care needs In older adults
City of Lubbock, Health Department 135303304
Related Category Project:
135103304.1.2
Starting Point/Baseline:
To be determined In OY3
Process Milestone 1: P-1
Process Milestone 2: P-2
Outcome Improvement Target 1:
Outcome Improvement Target 2:
Project planning —engage
Establish baseline rates
177.7: Urgent dental care needs in
IT7.7: Urgent dental care needs In
stakeholders, identify current
alder adults
older adults
capacity and needed resources,
determine timeliness and document
Improvement Target: Decrease the
Improvement Target:
implementation plans.
number of older adults 65 years or
Decrease the number of older adults
older with urgent dental care needs by
65 years or older with urgent dental
10% from baseline
care needs by 15% from baseline
Data Source: Implementation Plan
Data Source: PP Utilization Data,
Data Source: PP Utilization Data,
Data Source: PP Utilization Data,
Clinic Utilization Data
Clinic Utilization Data
Process Milestone 1 Estimated
Clinic Utilization Data
Incentive Payment: $15,639.47
Estimated Outcome Improvement
Estimated Outcome Improvement
Milestone 2 Estimated 1 Incentive
Target 1 Incentive Payment:
Target 2 Incentive Payment:
Payment:
$35,333.49
$73,848.93
$34,707.85
DY 2 Estimated Outcome Amount.
DY 3 Estimated Outcome Amount:
DY 4 Estimated Outcome Amount:
DY S Estimated Outcome Amount.
$15,639
$34,708
$35,333
$73,849
TOTAL ESTIMATED INCENTIVE PAYMENTS FOR 4 -YEAR PERIOD: $159,530
City of Lubbock Health Department - RHP 12 Plan Page 26 of 26